Well one implies that the Old Republic was around for 20,000-25,000 years while one states it has stood for 1000 years. That's a pretty big gap to reconcile.

Although I swore Obi-Wan says "guardians of peace and justice in the galaxy" not Old Republic...

It is, but does it really affect someone's movie experience? And simply saying that "this one is a faulty number because it feels wrong" isn't really that useful (you didn't say so or imply so, just to make it clear).



I'm pretty sure that he was talking about the Old Republic. I haven't watched ANH in some time, though, I could be wrong.

---

Confiteor Deo omnipotenti; beatae Mariae semper Virgini; beato Michaeli Archangelo; sanctis Apostolis, omnibus sanctis... Tibit Pater, quia peccavi nimis, cogitatione, verbo et opere, mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa! Kyrie Eleison!

The Imperial Senate (defunct) * Knights Astrum Clades * The Mess

Does it mess up the experience... no. However as we are in the midst of a chronological reissue of the movies in 3D, the two conflicting numbers go from being uttered 36 years apart and in the first movie and the 2nd to last, to being said only 2 years apart in the 2nd and 4th movie.

Like I said, it is something that raises questions. And you know me; if I am questioning it, you know the EU fans are going to be all over it.

Hey fuckwit, the Empire suppressed most of the information about the Jedi and either censored or destroyed most of anything that didn't have an Imperial spin

Also lol "civilisation"


Once again is why we have the Ruusan Reformation

Suppression I can actually understand, however the Jedi would have been all over the news casts during the clone wars yet by the time of A New Hope Jedi are dismissed as practitioners of a hokey old religion.

That's not suppression of information, you ignorant cum stain, that's galaxy wide mass amnesia.

---

In IMF controlled Ireland the banks rob the people.


PRFYNAFBTFC
Kirov Class MFS Dubious Use Of The Worlds Resources - If we can't fuck it, kill it

Hey fuckwit, I don't give two fucks about this Russian Formation... it's EU garbage.

I care about the movies and what is said in them.

Samurai haven't even existed for like 250 years and people idolize and know EVERYTHING about them... and that isn't even talking about JAPAN.

You think the Empire can just "suppress" TRILLIONS of memories of the Jedi in 30 fucking years? This is why you are an idiot and people like you are why they can successfully peddle the EU garbage they do.

The line still fails even if you toss out the prequels. If we stick with the facts as of Hope:
1) Anakin and Vader are separate people
2) Vader kills Anakin at some point
3) Luke is an orphan of no significance

The destruction of the Jedi would still be within living memory. Even if it took years to stamp them out and Anakin was among the last killed, this ain't the 18th century where a legendary group of warrior-monks and their abilities is passed down in written accounts. And Jedi abilities aren't just mind tricks that are easy to hoax on camera. Jedi are capable of doing things that should be impossible. To deny belief in the existence of Jedi powers isn't like questioning the real abilities of historic ninja, it's more like denying the existence of the dodo or saying that the moon landing didn't hapen.

If some dude in the here and now tells me he's a Druid, I'm going to laugh in his face. If he's able to raise a hand and make me choke, I won't say it's because he's a druid but I will say I have no idea how the hell he's doing it and I'm fucking terrified.

It was never made precisely clear what the Force is to the common citizen.

Religion: a set of beliefs concerning the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe, especially when considered as the creation of a superhuman agency or agencies, usually involving devotional and ritual observances, and often containing a moral code governing the conduct of human affairs.

Does the Jedi follow a religion or a code? Shaolin monks, certainly one of the inspirations for the Jedi, we could call that a religion. Bushido for the samurai? It operates within the same mythological constructs as Zen Buddhism and Shinto but I don't know if it in itself constitutes a religion.

Regardless, we do have plenty of examples in our own world of governments trying to stamp out religions and superstitions. China's had a miserable time with the Tibetans and the Falun Gong. The Soviets tried to stamp out Christianity but we still have the Russian Orthodox Church. People kept the faith despite several generations of official suppression.

Perhaps Imperial propaganda tried to explain away Jedi abilities as tricks and artifice rather than actually drawing upon an energy field existing throughout the universe and all matter. Maybe the accusation is that they're using advanced technology to simulate the appearance of magic to con the rubes.

You might explain Han's skepticism as sheer ignorance like denying the moon landing but we also have the example of the imperial officer mocking Vader to his face as if he's never seen the Sith choke a bitch before.

To be fair, only Karen Traviss believed there were only 1 million clones. Just so you know, she was shown the "Star Wars Door" personally by George Lucas after she got into a fit when Georgie crapped all over her Clone War and Legacy of the Force Mandalorians.

---

"Boring Conversation anyway" Han Solo

"What kinda archeologist carries a weapon........Bad Example" Colonel Jack O'Neil

"My name is Olo... Hans Olo" -Dr. Daniel Jackson

"Well you did make the Farmingdale Run in less than 12 parsecs" --Personal Quote

"Just popped out for lunch" - Rowan Atkinson as Mr. Bean

Given the lifespan of some of alien species in Star Wars plus how common picture phones are in first-world nations today plus the library of literally thousands of years of audio-video media spread across millions of planets much less space habits, star ships, probes and droids; there must be tremendous amounts of personal, eye-witness accounts of the Jedi and their dealings/abilities. Erasing that much cultural inertia galaxy-wide would require an effort in personal and attention that would likely dwarf the resources needed to build the Imperial Fleet and the Death Stars. It is one of the weakest claims made by the films and nearly breaks SoD when thought about.

---

"If you're caught with an ounce of cocaine, the chances are good you're going to jail. Evidently, if you launder nearly $1 billion for drug cartels and violate our international sanctions, your company pays a fine and you go home and sleep in your own bed at night." Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)


The Noldor are the Wise, and the Golden, the Valiant, the Sword-elves, the Elves of the Earth, the Foes of Melkor, the Skilled of Hand, the Jewel-wrights, the Companions of Men, the Followers of Finwë.

Wait George Lucas himself told her to get out?

---

"Lexx takes politically correct Star Trek-style sci-fi, murders its conventions, and then urinates on their graves" Darth Wong on LEXX

"Screw the Rules I Have Money" Yugioh the Abridged Series.

"But then again as a kid I wanted the planeeters to die horrible deaths when Captain Planet was on TV"-Sarevok

Are you seriously claiming the Jedi were just forgotten after 10 years? You don't think it had ANYTHING to do with the authoritarian government controlled by the Sith repressing knowledge? I mean they weren't even... we're just riding along on this fantasy of yours, it was maybe half an hour into A New Hope before Obi Wan started to relay oral history from before the purge, and Yoda's 800 fucking years old but suuuuuure knowledge is lost after ten years. Ire you better get right on answering that little ultimatum

only because you brought it up, during the Meiji and Taisho military regimes in Japan, the Samurai ideology was banned. Even talking about about the Samurai or keeping Samurai weapons and armor were illegal.

I don't see why Palpatine would not do something similar against the Jedi. If you have a generation brought up with no history of the Jedi and no one ever talking about them you would believe they were members of a hokey religion. As for the people who had first hand knowledge of what the Jedi actually were, we call them members of the Rebel Alliance.

---

"Boring Conversation anyway" Han Solo

"What kinda archeologist carries a weapon........Bad Example" Colonel Jack O'Neil

"My name is Olo... Hans Olo" -Dr. Daniel Jackson

"Well you did make the Farmingdale Run in less than 12 parsecs" --Personal Quote

"Just popped out for lunch" - Rowan Atkinson as Mr. Bean

And yet, even though they were banned from being talked about, their mythology not only didn't go anywhere, it grew.

And are you insinuating that only members of the Rebel Alliance remember or knew Jedi or thought they were good?

All I was insinuating ::shifty eyes:: was that the ones who remember the Jedi for what they were and did something joined the Rebel Alliance.

I know you don't follow/like the EU, but by the time the Imperial Remnant finally signed an end to conflict treaty with the Alliance ~35 years passed since the Emperors death. The problem for Luke's New Jedi Order was not that people forgot what the Jedi were, it really is the opposite. The generation that is now in power was brought up in a galaxy that saw Jedi and Sith constantly going at it. People tend to forget what someone did years ago, all they care about is "What can you do for me now".

I don't know how we got onto Luke's New Jedi Order when the thread was about the Dawn of the Je'daii, but there you go

---

"Boring Conversation anyway" Han Solo

"What kinda archeologist carries a weapon........Bad Example" Colonel Jack O'Neil

"My name is Olo... Hans Olo" -Dr. Daniel Jackson

"Well you did make the Farmingdale Run in less than 12 parsecs" --Personal Quote

"Just popped out for lunch" - Rowan Atkinson as Mr. Bean

The Jedi would have been subjected to a debunking claim, and most people hadn't seen a jedi ever (there are 10000 in AOTC and lets face it in a galaxy of trillions thats small potatoes). So I can see why many wouldn't believe. Many people are ignorant and refuse to believe anything their eyes don't show.

---

"Lexx takes politically correct Star Trek-style sci-fi, murders its conventions, and then urinates on their graves" Darth Wong on LEXX

"Screw the Rules I Have Money" Yugioh the Abridged Series.

"But then again as a kid I wanted the planeeters to die horrible deaths when Captain Planet was on TV"-Sarevok

The Jedi would have been subjected to a debunking claim, and most people hadn't seen a jedi ever (there are 10000 in AOTC and lets face it in a galaxy of trillions thats small potatoes). So I can see why many wouldn't believe. Many people are ignorant and refuse to believe anything their eyes don't show.

---

"Lexx takes politically correct Star Trek-style sci-fi, murders its conventions, and then urinates on their graves" Darth Wong on LEXX

"Screw the Rules I Have Money" Yugioh the Abridged Series.

"But then again as a kid I wanted the planeeters to die horrible deaths when Captain Planet was on TV"-Sarevok

Is it just me, or does everything thread somehow devolve from its original topic and become a EU vs Movie Purist argument? I'm kind of sick of hearing it. If you don't like EU, DON'T FUCKING READ IT. That simple really. Shouldn't be any arguments or discussions, because those that do not like the EU won't know what they are talking about and wouldn't want to talk about it in the first place. Those that do like EU can then have their own little game in the corner so as not to disturb the people that dislike the EU.

It. Is. That. Simple. Let. It. Fucking. Die. Already.

Back to main topic:

I think so far that the Dawn of the Jedi series is pretty awesome. I like that they are going into detail about the rise of the Rakata and even to the very creation of the Jedi. I hope to see some more information regarding the Celestials and maybe some information regarding The Ones who are somehow suppose to be avatars or embodiments of the Force. I like the old Jedi philosophy that they have created, by combining the two opposing forces into a balanced one. Reminded me of Avatar the Last Airbender in that effect.

I'm looking forward to seeing how they create the pivotal character that will ultimately become the leader of the Dark Side/Bogan forces that will cause the Force Wars, or at least lead to that divide. It's a topic that has never been given much detail, even in the sourcebooks.

I'm betting Xesh might be the cause seeing how his approach to Tython was treated as a important event

True, but I'm thinking that because Xesh is an outsider (I am presuming that he was not a Je'dii before he became a Hound) that it won't cause as much a rift than if one of the Je'dii themselves fell totally into the Dark Side. Maybe Xesh trains the person that does fall?

It's either him or Daegen Lok since he also had a vision of Xesh

Edit: Sense the the fact that he had the vision implies he also has a role at some point

I didn't imply they were merely forgotten after ten years, Imperial propaganda and alteration and destruction of records etc obviously had a role. I think we simply had an error in communication, or I made a mistake somewhere.

If the Chinese government can completely erase the Tienanmen Square incident from modern Chinese history less than twenty years after the fact (meaning anyone born from 1989+ has no clue what happened) then I expect the Galactic Empire could just as easily erase the Jedi Order to all but an old boogie man story to scary Imp kids before going to bed.

You're an idiot.

You are comparing a single isolated incident on one day, in one country, on one planet to literally millions of accounts for over 10,000 years in an entire civilized galaxy.

Come the fuck on.