Federation is only one with working Interphase Cloak, and definetly has knowledge to build it. Only reason it's not using it is Treaty of Algeron.
Bullshit. It was stated that the Klingons had been working on it, and we have an entire episode involving a romulan phase cloak.
See? You DO ignore canon when it doesn't suit your madness. It's not that you dismiss the EU, but you even ignore ST-canon when you have to.
And besides - what makes you think they will immediately ignore the treaty of algeron, even tough they did not do it during the Dominon War, even tough they were allied with the Romulans?
Furthermore, since the cloak and phase-parts of the thing are apparently separate, why didn't they build just the phase-part? Given that it would make their ships virtually invulnerable, any sensible military would go after it no matter what.
No, but they are supposed to destroy other ships, and were quite capable of doing it. Just basic logic.
You fail utterly at logic. Just because something is supposed to do something, it can't automatically do it. Especially when it's still a prototype. That's not even logic, that's just basic common sense.
Shields of Death Star I could be passed throught without any technobabble. Since we never saw shields of DSII in action, it is only thing we can take as evidence.
The Empire is very capable of building shields that stop physical impacts. They can easily equip the second Death Star with them if they want to. That they choose not do do so with the first Death Star is no proof, given that there are many possible reasons not to do it - such as enemy ships (supposedly) being no threat, or the fact that ramming attacks are utterly useless anyway.
...and yet we see them routinely scanning for and detecting ships light years away. In "Silicon Avatar" Enterprise detects "disturbance" on Melana 4 while at warp. It is "27 hours away", which means minimum distance of 27 light hours. They were below warp 8, so I would take maximum distance to be 2 light years (at warp 7, since starships tend to travel at non-decimal warp factors). In "Wounded", effective range of sensors when searching for starship that did not wish to be found was 10 light years. Plus we don't know which stealth systems that shuttle had, and Data did not wish to be found.
Moron. The (tangential) point was that ST-sensors are sometimes WORSE than the MK I Eyeball and basic optic instruments.
But nooo, you just went "SW-sensors=suck" without any logic, intelligence or proof behind it.
It is most logical explanation, and fits with visual evidence.
Idiot. You jumped to that conclusion without examining the evidence.
Given that the Death Star is not yet finished, there is a very simple explanation for those holes. Given that it is NOT a shaft, concluding that it IS a shaft is moronic.
For you, a "contradiction" is apparently "everything i claim G-canon says can override anything i want", even when it's just one of your delusions!
Repeat after me: Picard has zero evidence that the DS II had a large thermal exhaust shaft. Picard has zero evidence that the DS II had a large thermal exhaust shaft. Picard has zero evidence that the DS II had a large thermal exhaust shaft.
If you HAVE such evidence, present it. However, the film never states what it was. The film shows that it was not a straight shaft, but rather a meddled assembly of open ways inside the Death Star.
Repeating your claims doesn't make them true. Ignoring your opponents arguments makes you an idiot. Ignoring evidence makes you a liar.
You are all of the above.