[Stewart at SDI] Ultimatum for Stewart Davies

Darth Wong

Stewart, you have repeatedly claimed that it is impossible for the Death Star to dump its waste heat, when it is in fact a simple matter of numbers. With an arbitrarily low inefficiency for the turbolaser assembly, the numbers can easily be rationalized. For example, if the efficiency is (1-1E-20), then the Death Star can easily dissipate the waste heat from a 2.4E32 J blast with a mere 30 W/m^2 surface radiation intensity. Similarly, a 1E38 J blast could be dissipated similarly if efficiency is (1-1E-26), all without taking the presence of active heat dissipation systems into effect.

Now, I have produced the numbers you demanded. They may be technologically infeasible, but they are not scientifically impossible. YOU HAVE CLAIMED THAT YOUR ALTERNATE THEORY IS FEASIBLE. THIS MEANS YOU SHOULD BE ABLE TO PRODUCE CALCULATIONS SHOWING THIS TO BE THE CASE, OTHERWISE YOU HAVE BEEN LYING THE WHOLE TIME AND YOU ACTUALLY HAVE NO IDEA WHETHER IT IS FEASIBLE OR EVEN SCIENTIFICALLY POSSIBLE.

So, YOU HAVE 24 HOURS TO PRODUCE CALCULATIONS SHOWING THAT YOUR ALTERNATE MECHANISM IS SCIENTIFICALLY POSSIBLE AND WOULD REQUIRE LESS ACTIVATION ENERGY THAN THE CONVENTIONAL ONE.

We're all tired of your bullshit, Stewart. You claim to be a nuclear weapons expert, and tout this totally unverified and heretofore completely unsubstantiated "expertise" at every opportunity. You now have 24 hours to prove it. Let's see those calculations, shithead.

Darth Wong · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-23 03:05pm

No answer yet, eh? We're almost halfway to the deadline, Stewart. And by the way, you'd better not pull the moronic Stilgar trick of calculating the output of the reaction and ignoring the question of how much energy it takes to make it happen in the first place.

You've been claiming "nuclear weapons expertise" without ever demonstrating a shred of knowledge that anyone couldn't get from Google; well now you're being forced to either put up or shut the fuck up. What's it going to be, Stewart?

Master of Ossus · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-23 09:41pm

Just a little bumpage to make sure Stewie doesn't miss it.

Andrew J. · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-23 09:45pm

Sorry to aska stupid question, but what will happen to him when he misses the deadline? A ban?

Darth Wong · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-23 10:55pm

T - 5.5 hours.

Darth Wong · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 01:52am

T - 2.5 hours.

The Kernel · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 02:10am

He's been posting, but he seems to be ignoring your threat. I guess he must figure you are either bluffing or not serious in your demand.

Howedar · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 02:27am

He wouldn't be the first to make that mistake.

fgalkin · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 02:51am

Maybe we should start a list of trolls who ignored Wong's warning. But then, that would include most of them.

Have a very nice day.
-fgalkin

Darth Wong · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 03:57am

Half an hour left, Stewart. WHERE ARE THOSE CALCULATIONS, MR. NUCLEAR WEAPONS EXPERT? DON'T HAVE THE BALLS TO ADMIT YOU WERE LYING?

Darth Wong · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:03am

Howedar wrote:

He wouldn't be the first to make that mistake.

What's most amazing is that most of them E-mail me after the ultimatum passes, whining that I had no right to follow through on my ultimatum and that I should let them back in.

Patrick Degan · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:25am

Hmm... Ten minutes left, Stewpid. Better get crackin' with those sums.

Slartibartfast · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:31am

Now...come on, Stu, old buddy. Don't let me down.

consequences · **Joined:** 2002-07-07 03:06pm **Posts:** 6927

5...
4...
3...
2...
1...
Bzzzttt! Goodbye.

Ace Pace · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:35am

3 more minutes on my clock.

consequences · **Joined:** 2002-07-07 03:06pm **Posts:** 6927

Going from the time of Darth Wong's post, mine was right on the 24 hour mark.

Patrick Degan · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:40am

YOU NOW HAVE TWO MINUTES

AdmiralKanos · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:46am

Goodbye, Stewtard. I'm not surprised at all that you couldn't come up with a single calculation to back up any of your claims. In the end, you made it very clear that any numbers on your part were pure conjecture, and that any claims on your part were pure bullshit. How long did you think you could get away with claiming advanced technical expertise without knowing how to do any of the calculations behind your numbers, moron?

You're gone. Don't let the door hit your ass on the way out.

consequences · **Joined:** 2002-07-07 03:06pm **Posts:** 6927

Just out of curiosity, are you going to give him any sort of grace period to see that he's been banned, or are you going to let the 'Forbidden' message stand for itself?

Crown · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 04:59am

If Stewie does produce some numbers, he could always email Mike saying so.

Patrick Degan · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 05:12am

Hmm, guess that wraps it up for Stewpid. At least he was a bit more entertaining than some of our recent guest idiots here at SDN.

aerius · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 11:47am

That was fun. It's gonna be a while till another idiot as entertaining as Stewie was shows up again. "All 8 PhD plus types agreed with me!" Oh boy... :lol:

Howedar · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 12:59pm

Crown wrote:

If Stewie does produce some numbers, he could always email Mike saying so.

Indeed, if calcs were part of a begging-to-come-back email, I'd see no reason not to let him back in.

I am, of course, holding my breath waiting for these calculations. Because believe me, I'm sure Stewie indeed calculated all of these things, but since he is only the SDI Dean of Technology, he had trouble inputting them into the computer or scanning them off of a piece of paper.

Don't worry Stewie, some of us still have faith in you!

BoredShirtless · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 01:16pm

Howedar wrote:

some of us still have faith in you!

1 != some

General Zod · **Post subject:** **Posted:** 2004-03-24 01:21pm

Howedar wrote:

Crown wrote:

If Stewie does produce some numbers, he could always email Mike saying so.

Indeed, if calcs were part of a begging-to-come-back email, I'd see no reason not to let him back in.

I am, of course, holding my breath waiting for these calculations. Because believe me, I'm sure Stewie indeed calculated all of these things, but since he is only the SDI Dean of Technology, he had trouble inputting them into the computer or scanning them off of a piece of paper.

Don't worry Stewie, some of us still have faith in you!

he may not even be able to work your average scientific calculator. if he can't figure out a scanner to work, there's no way in hell he'd be able to figure out one of those.

[Stewart at SDI] Ultimatum for Stewart Davies

Who is online