StarDestroyer.Net BBS

Some time ago it was debated if borg drones had KE shields and the drone One was used as an example. As was said One doesn’t count as he was an advanced drone but in the same episode we saw an ordinary drone with a KE shield.

I have the TOS DVD season 1 last disc, on that their is a trailer for Voyager DVD’s. On time: 01, 42 you clearly see that the normal drone has KE shields.

Hope that clears that.

What is the evidence that this is a KE shield? This sounds alot like a few newbies who have, in fact, invented whole new episodes out of thin air to try and win debates, because there's frankly nothing to explain how it's a KE shield or anything at all, really. Just an assertion.

SirNitram wrote:invented whole new episodes out of thin air to try and win debates,

Are you saing that I invented that whole episode.

Gustav32Vasa wrote:Some time ago it was debated if borg drones had KE shields and the drone One was used as an example. As was said One doesn’t count as he was an advanced drone but in the same episode we saw an ordinary drone with a KE shield.

I have the TOS DVD season 1 last disc, on that their is a trailer for Voyager DVD’s. On time: 01, 42 you clearly see that the normal drone has KE shields.

Hope that clears that.

care to provide screencaps of said KE shield in action? or on screen dialogue verifying they in fact have one? otherwise it's pointless spec. If the borg do have a KE shield then how come the bullets fired by the tommy gun at the borg in first contact in the holodeck affected them just fine?

I'll have agree with Nitram here. Unless you will provide better evidence (like a pic of the incedent) I'm not holding my breath.

Gustav32Vasa wrote:

SirNitram wrote:invented whole new episodes out of thin air to try and win debates,

Are you saing that I invented that whole episode.

I am demanding more info because it smells fishy. Such as why you can say so firmly it's a KE shield. Something distinctly lacking in your above assertion.

Darth_Zod wrote:care to provide screencaps of said KE shield in action?

I dont know how to do that, hopefully someone here have seen that DVD, if not just ignore this thread.

If the borg do have a KE shield then how come the bullets fired by the tommy gun at the borg in first contact in the holodeck affected them just fine?

They may have assimilated it after FC.

Regarding if it was a KE shield. It pushed the drone backwards.

Gustav32Vasa wrote:Regarding if it was a KE shield. It pushed the drone backwards.

Not much of a KE shield then.

SirNitram wrote:I am demanding more info because it smells fishy. Such as why you can say so firmly it's a KE shield. Something distinctly lacking in your above assertion.

Oh, sorry.

When I was looking throught the DVD I saw the scene in questions and paused and it is clearly somekind of shield around both drones. You cant miss it.

Gustav32Vasa wrote:

SirNitram wrote:I am demanding more info because it smells fishy. Such as why you can say so firmly it's a KE shield. Something distinctly lacking in your above assertion.

Oh, sorry.

When I was looking throught the DVD I saw the scene in questions and paused and it is clearly somekind of shield around both drones. You cant miss it.

Wow. Borg have shields. We've known this since Q Who. What about the scene makes it so clear they're KE shields? That the drones are physically buffetted? That would imply they are not being protected from kinetic effects!

Grand Admiral Thrawn wrote:Use this, post clips

I dont have a DVD player on my computer.

SirNitram wrote:

Gustav32Vasa wrote:Regarding if it was a KE shield. It pushed the drone backwards.

Not much of a KE shield then.

One's shield was more powerful? You can see that One stand erect with the field around himself (itself?) while the ordinary drone is thrown back.

Come on, the DVD's was discussed a while ago. No one here has them?

Gustav32Vasa wrote:

SirNitram wrote:

Gustav32Vasa wrote:Regarding if it was a KE shield. It pushed the drone backwards.

Not much of a KE shield then.

One's shield was more powerful? You can see that One stand erect with the field around himself (itself?) while the ordinary drone is thrown back.

Come on, the DVD's was discussed a while ago. No one here has them?

More than likely no one is seeing what you're seeing. Are you going to clarify, for example, what hits these drones? Good gods, this is like pulling fucking hen's teeth!

SirNitram wrote:Wow. Borg have shields. We've known this since Q Who. What about the scene makes it so clear they're KE shields? That the drones are physically buffetted? That would imply they are not being protected from kinetic effects!

The drones shield was weaker then Ones' I guess.

ps, Have some one here actually made up a episode and used it as evidence for something?

SirNitram wrote:More than likely no one is seeing what you're seeing. Are you going to clarify, for example, what hits these drones? Good gods, this is like pulling fucking hen's teeth!

One stands on the sphere's deck. One drone walks towards him and the instant they touch eachother the ordinary drone is flung back. Both drones has some field around them.

Gustav32Vasa wrote:

SirNitram wrote:Wow. Borg have shields. We've known this since Q Who. What about the scene makes it so clear they're KE shields? That the drones are physically buffetted? That would imply they are not being protected from kinetic effects!

The drones shield was weaker then Ones' I guess.

Or it provides no defense against KE, but we can't tell, because you're not telling us anything.

ps, Have some one here actually made up a episode and used it as evidence for something?

Yes. Someone made up an episode of Enterprise and claimed it included a weapon which dialogue placed in the Teraton range. It was blatant penis envy to try and get back at the Episode II ICS that was released for Star Wars.

Gustav32Vasa wrote:

SirNitram wrote:More than likely no one is seeing what you're seeing. Are you going to clarify, for example, what hits these drones? Good gods, this is like pulling fucking hen's teeth!

One stands on the sphere's deck. One drone walks towards him and the instant they touch eachother the ordinary drone is flung back. Both drones has some field around them.

Oh, wow. One is your evidence? Okay, so your evidence is that a Borg Drone built with 29th Century technology known to include tacitile forcefields has a KE shield. Given that the other drone is physically fucking flung would suggest to an astute observer that he had no protection against KE.

In short, the reason no one is backing you up is because we saw this years ago and knew it wasn't a KE shield.

SirNitram wrote:

ps, Have some one here actually made up a episode and used it as evidence for something?

Yes. Someone made up an episode of Enterprise and claimed it included a weapon which dialogue placed in the Teraton range. It was blatant penis envy to try and get back at the Episode II ICS that was released for Star Wars.

That’s stupid. When no one can remember such episode and when looking it up and sees that that episode doesn’t exist its over.

SirNitram wrote:In short, the reason no one is backing you up is because we saw this years ago and knew it wasn't a KE shield.

Then why would a forcefield surround the other drone. If only One had KE shields wouldn’t the other drone be thrown back without a shield around itself?

Gustav32Vasa wrote:

SirNitram wrote:In short, the reason no one is backing you up is because we saw this years ago and knew it wasn't a KE shield.

Then why would a forcefield surround the other drone. If only One had KE shields wouldn’t the other drone be thrown back without a shield around itself?

Why are you starting with the assumption it's a KE shield? That's completely ass backwards. There is no evidence at all it was protected from kinetic or momentum effects. There is, in fact, evidence against it. Why a shield appears is academic; it does not provide the requisite effects you asserted.

SirNitram wrote:Why are you starting with the assumption it's a KE shield? That's completely ass backwards. There is no evidence at all it was protected from kinetic or momentum effects. There is, in fact, evidence against it. Why a shield appears is academic; it does not provide the requisite effects you asserted.

Alright I concede defeat. I just found it on the DVD and I didn’t realise that it was such hot topic.

But I hope that someone here can uplink the pic at 01, 42.

Ok, Gust...just to firmly resolve your claim, is this the scene you're talking about?

Robert Walper wrote:Ok, Gust...just to firmly resolve your claim, is this the scene you're talking about?

Let's not quote images

Almost, one second later. But you get the point.

Let's follow your logic, shall we?

A) KE shields make objects bounce off
B) The drone bounces off The One's shield
C) Therefore, the One's shield is a KE shield
D) Something lights up around the drone when he bounces off
E) This can't be his energy shield interacting with The One's KE shield because ...
F) Therefore, the drone's shield is also a KE shield

So sorry, but you lose. Next time, try actual logic.