StarDestroyer.Net BBS

I saw Nemesis last night. So here is how I rate the ST films (best to worst):

FC, TUC, TWoK, Nemesis, TVH, TSFS, Insurrection, Generations, TMP, TFF.

YOU PUT FIRST CONTACT BEFORE KHAN AND TUC?!??!?

You though "Nemesis" was better than TVH? I thought ST:IV was one of their better films.

Darth Garden Gnome wrote:YOU PUT FIRST CONTACT BEFORE KHAN AND TUC?!??!?

Borg may be stupid and incompetent, but they are still really awesome. Besides, the action covered over the shitty plot.

Nemesis I haven't seen, so I'll rank the first nine:

II, VI, IV, FC, III, Gen, I, V, In

First Contact is the only TNG film I'd voluntarily watch again, BTW.

For me it has to be:

II
VI
III
I
IV
V

The next Generation films suck...which is a shame because I liked the Next Generation series.

For me the first 6 (yes even number 5) are rewatchable adinfinum. I tire of FC after the crew split up between the Enterprise and Earth.

*Initial shock fades*

Ok, here's my list.

ST: TWOK
ST: TUC
ST: TVH
ST: FC
ST: NEM
ST: IN
ST: TMP
ST: TFF
ST: GEN

Curiously, I've never seen ST: TSFS, so I won't rate it.

My Ranking:

ST VI
ST II
ST VIII
ST IV
ST III
ST VII
ST V
ST I
ST IX
ST X

TWOK
TUC
TSFS
TVH
FC
I
N
TFF
G
TMP

Top to bottom:

TWOK
TMP/TFF
TUC
TSFS/TVH

If i had to put the NextGen stuff in, FC (and now NEM) would be down there with the Nimoy-directed pics at the bottom, with INS & GEN slightly above it, but still WAY below TUC.

TWoK
TUC
FC
Tie between TVH and SFS
TMP
G
TFF

No surprises there, then.

TWOK
TUC
FC
NEM
TVH
I
TSFS
G
TMP
TFF

TWOK
TUC
TVH
NEM
FC
I
ST3
ST5
GEN


I have not seen TMP.

TWOK

TUD

FC

NEMESIS

TVH

TSFS

TMP

INS

GEN

TFF