When did the borg get/invent nanoprobes?

PST: discuss Star Trek without "versus" arguments.

Moderator: Vympel

User avatar
Luzifer's right hand
Jedi Master
Posts: 1417
Joined: 2003-11-30 01:45pm
Location: Austria

Post by Luzifer's right hand »

I expect a pig could be a short-term blood donor for a human patient (since other pig parts are used for human replacement - if someone knows I'm wrong on this, please speak up). We know from TNG that Romulans are too different from humans to share blood. I think we know that Romulans have/can be assimilated, but I'm not sure on that one. If they have, then the Borg can assimilate a bigger difference in blood cells than between pigs and humans.
Pig cells have a sugar molecule on their surface that causes human antibodies to destroy the organ. Researchers have focused on making transgenic pigs with modified sugar molecules that prevent the antibodies from killing the pig cells.

Research has also shown that animal transplantation could even result in animal viruses crossing over into the human population, through pig and human viruses recombining, although this is unlikely.

They already use porcine tissue of course, untreated porcine tissue would be rejected very quickly by the recipient's body, in the same way that a human's donated organ would be rejected. To prevent this, porcine heart valves are treated with glutaraldehyde to reduce their immunogenicity.
I asked The Lord, "Why hath thou forsaken me?" And He spoke unto me saying, "j00 R n00b 4 3VR", And I was like "stfu -_-;;"
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Howedar wrote:
Gil Hamilton wrote:There could be other reasons as well.
For one thing nanoprobes are really tiny, and thus can't possibly have huge amounts of memory or lots of variation in their structures. A nanomachine that wants to assimilate a cell may have to go through the same way natural cell assimilators (viruses) do it. Viruses can't go after just any cell, they need to look for specific structures on the cell to connect to, in order to stick their pirate code into the cell to take it over. These cell structures very from species to species, so a virus that effects Fido won't likely be contagious to humans (though stranger things have happened), while chimp viruses have a much better chance of transmitting to humans. Since all humanoid species in StarTrek seem to be biologically human, a generic human cell virus would be useful, since the nanobots then don't have to carry huge amount of memory, processing power, or mutability to work with. It explains why they can't do things that too greatly vary from your bog standard human, and it also explains why a sufficently high immune response will beat them. The body treats the invaders like any virus, and the white blood cells hit the same connectors that the nanobots use to convert cells into nanobot factories or make them receptive to implants.
I expect a pig could be a short-term blood donor for a human patient (since other pig parts are used for human replacement - if someone knows I'm wrong on this, please speak up). We know from TNG that Romulans are too different from humans to share blood. I think we know that Romulans have/can be assimilated, but I'm not sure on that one. If they have, then the Borg can assimilate a bigger difference in blood cells than between pigs and humans.
Romulans have canonly been assimilated by the Borg. Ref STVOY "Unity".
That is a distinct possibility that the Borg Cubes simply don't have the bandwidth to network that many organisms effective and that the collective power of the network drones don't have the processing power, thus resulting in jerky and clumsy motor functions. Then again, Hugh was severed from the collective and he remained as jerky and clumsy as ever in "I, Borg". So did Seven, before they got her out of the rubber body sock with all the hardware mounted all over it.
You're right about Hugh and Seven. Perhaps it takes longer for bodies to be accustomed to moving more human-like? One wouldn't just magically get used to moving completely differently, presumably the brain would be more used to moving like a Borg. But I can't support that theory, so I concede that particular argument.
But we don't know that CyberFido has the same slow speed as normal drones. Remember, my idea for CyberFido only adds extended EM range goggles for his eyes and a harness with a small manipulator arm, plus a nanobot gun on his nose. Aside from slow connection issues with the collective, I can't see why CyberFido would be any slower than a normal dog, since it's not like he's wearing a big rubber suit with half of RadioShack on it.
But the Borg could do this with a humanoid and it'd still be vastly superior to their normal drones. The Borg are apparently either uninterested in superior drones, or they're too stupid to figure out how to improve them. Either one would rule out CyberFido.
Besides, the question still stands. If the Borg can and do assimilate non-humanoids, then where are they?
As Robert suggests, they may just not be interested.
This has been canonly stated(ref STVOY "Raven"). The Borg consider species of lesser devolopment unworthy of assimilation. The Borg have even deemed humanoid lifeforms unworthy of assimilation(ie the Kazon).

As I stated before, and will again, Species 8472 is a non humanoid organism. Borg nanoprobes, once modified to elude the superior immune system, can target and assimilate Species 8472 blood cells with apparent ease.

Species 8472 organism are even capable of shapeshifting and becoming almost indistingishable from human beings(presumeably able to immitate other humanoid lifeforms as well). Despite this vast difference in size and apparent makeup, Borg nanopobes can still assimilate them.
User avatar
Gil Hamilton
Tipsy Space Birdie
Posts: 12962
Joined: 2002-07-04 05:47pm
Contact:

Post by Gil Hamilton »

Howedar wrote:I expect a pig could be a short-term blood donor for a human patient (since other pig parts are used for human replacement - if someone knows I'm wrong on this, please speak up). We know from TNG that Romulans are too different from humans to share blood. I think we know that Romulans have/can be assimilated, but I'm not sure on that one. If they have, then the Borg can assimilate a bigger difference in blood cells than between pigs and humans.
Yet Romulans are similar enough to produce offspring (IE Sela). That makes Romulans biologically human.
But the Borg could do this with a humanoid and it'd still be vastly superior to their normal drones. The Borg are apparently either uninterested in superior drones, or they're too stupid to figure out how to improve them. Either one would rule out CyberFido.
My idea was hypothetical to demonstrate a point. Humans aren't exactly the optimal thing that the above posters are making them out to be as the reason why the Borg only assimilate non-humans.
As Robert suggests, they may just not be interested.
But his idea that the Borg are only interested in humanoids because they are working toward perfection is silly. Humans are far from perfect. We think slowly, are fragile, and expensive to maintain. There are bound to be better critters in the galaxy for assimilation, or even not bother and use real automation, if they wanted to be perfect.
"Show me an angel and I will paint you one." - Gustav Courbet

"Quetzalcoatl, plumed serpent of the Aztecs... you are a pussy." - Stephen Colbert

"Really, I'm jealous of how much smarter than me he is. I'm not an expert on anything and he's an expert on things he knows nothing about." - Me, concerning a bullshitter
User avatar
Gil Hamilton
Tipsy Space Birdie
Posts: 12962
Joined: 2002-07-04 05:47pm
Contact:

Post by Gil Hamilton »

Robert Walper wrote:As I stated before, and will again, Species 8472 is a non humanoid organism. Borg nanoprobes, once modified to elude the superior immune system, can target and assimilate Species 8472 blood cells with apparent ease.

Species 8472 organism are even capable of shapeshifting and becoming almost indistingishable from human beings(presumeably able to immitate other humanoid lifeforms as well). Despite this vast difference in size and apparent makeup, Borg nanopobes can still assimilate them.
That's the thing, the nanobots can't assimilate them. After they figured out how to prevent the S8472's auto-immune system from killing the nanobots, the nanobots didn't assimilate the S8472 cells, they destroyed them in the attempt. That counts as a failure in the assimilation column, since destroying a cell renders it useless. Therefore, even with the modified nanobots, they still can't assimilate them.

It's like saying "I performed surgery! Unfortunately, the patient ended up hacked up into cutlets in the process..."
"Show me an angel and I will paint you one." - Gustav Courbet

"Quetzalcoatl, plumed serpent of the Aztecs... you are a pussy." - Stephen Colbert

"Really, I'm jealous of how much smarter than me he is. I'm not an expert on anything and he's an expert on things he knows nothing about." - Me, concerning a bullshitter
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Gil Hamilton wrote:
Robert Walper wrote:As I stated before, and will again, Species 8472 is a non humanoid organism. Borg nanoprobes, once modified to elude the superior immune system, can target and assimilate Species 8472 blood cells with apparent ease.

Species 8472 organism are even capable of shapeshifting and becoming almost indistingishable from human beings(presumeably able to immitate other humanoid lifeforms as well). Despite this vast difference in size and apparent makeup, Borg nanopobes can still assimilate them.
That's the thing, the nanobots can't assimilate them. After they figured out how to prevent the S8472's auto-immune system from killing the nanobots, the nanobots didn't assimilate the S8472 cells, they destroyed them in the attempt.
Only when the Doctor modifed the nanoprobes to cease function after attacking said cells. He stated so in STVOY "Scorpion". It makes sense, given he wouldn't want Harry Kim assimilated by them.
That counts as a failure in the assimilation column, since destroying a cell renders it useless. Therefore, even with the modified nanobots, they still can't assimilate them.
STVOY "In the Flesh" clearly showed the Doctor injecting a Species 8472 with his modified nanoprobes. The speciman was assimilated.

Anyway, the entire point is moot, because the arguement was that Borg nanoprobes would be unable to recognize non humanoid blood cells. Clearly they can.
Howedar
Emperor's Thumb
Posts: 12472
Joined: 2002-07-03 05:06pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Howedar »

Gil Hamilton wrote:Yet Romulans are similar enough to produce offspring (IE Sela). That makes Romulans biologically human.
Clearly there is a discrepancy here (shocking!).
My idea was hypothetical to demonstrate a point. Humans aren't exactly the optimal thing that the above posters are making them out to be as the reason why the Borg only assimilate non-humans.
No, they're not.
But his idea that the Borg are only interested in humanoids because they are working toward perfection is silly. Humans are far from perfect. We think slowly, are fragile, and expensive to maintain. There are bound to be better critters in the galaxy for assimilation, or even not bother and use real automation, if they wanted to be perfect.
Dogs think slowly, are no less fragile, and are no easier to mantain.

As for the "perfection" bit, I think it's fair to assume that some of that is simple preference for humanoids (the collective mind likes more of it's own or something). I dunno.
Howedar is no longer here. Need to talk to him? Talk to Pick.
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Howedar wrote:
Gil Hamilton wrote:Yet Romulans are similar enough to produce offspring (IE Sela). That makes Romulans biologically human.
Clearly there is a discrepancy here (shocking!).
It should be noted there is absolutely no reason to discount the possibility Commander Sela was also conceived with signficant artificial assistance. Proposing this theory would eliminate said discrepancy.
Howedar
Emperor's Thumb
Posts: 12472
Joined: 2002-07-03 05:06pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Howedar »

Yar got used for pleasure, and Sela "was the result". It didn't sound like she was an intentional byproduct of the relationship.
Howedar is no longer here. Need to talk to him? Talk to Pick.
User avatar
Luzifer's right hand
Jedi Master
Posts: 1417
Joined: 2003-11-30 01:45pm
Location: Austria

Post by Luzifer's right hand »

Robert Walper wrote:Then why couldn't the E-D's crew, a mix of many alien species, give a simple blood transfer to a Romulan prisoner? Why was Worf the only one with compatible physiology, if all Trek races are so similar?
blood transfer incompatibility ::sigh::
You think someone is an alien if nobody from 1000 people has a compatible blood group?
[url=http:///rare-chart.html]rare blood types[/url]
Robert Walper wrote:Why did only Kes has the only compatiable organ for Neelix's missing lung? Why not any crewmember? Voyager has many different species onboard. Plenty, with your assertion, that are so biogically compatible.
You are incredible lucky if you find one suitable organ donor, if you can only chose from 100 people. This is evidence for my a point of view not yours.


Do you believe that every human is a suitable organ donor for another human?

Your assertion fails not mine.
I asked The Lord, "Why hath thou forsaken me?" And He spoke unto me saying, "j00 R n00b 4 3VR", And I was like "stfu -_-;;"
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Howedar wrote:Yar got used for pleasure, and Sela "was the result". It didn't sound like she was an intentional byproduct of the relationship.
That would strike me as a likely scenario. But simply being used for pleasure doesn't imply she was impregnanted without artificial assistance. We do know that a pure human and pure Klingon cannot procreate without plenty of artificial assistance. It may be the same with Rolumans and humans. I don't think Sela is adaquate evidence to argue either side effectively.
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Luzifer's right hand wrote:
Robert Walper wrote:Then why couldn't the E-D's crew, a mix of many alien species, give a simple blood transfer to a Romulan prisoner? Why was Worf the only one with compatible physiology, if all Trek races are so similar?
blood transfer incompatibility ::sigh::
Yes, I was corrected by SDF's on that issue. I stand corrected.

However, I will point out that rare blood types are just that...rare.

I haven't seen the episode in question for a long time, but I suspect the blood donor problem was not simply(or at all) one of blood type.
Robert Walper wrote:Why did only Kes has the only compatiable organ for Neelix's missing lung? Why not any crewmember? Voyager has many different species onboard. Plenty, with your assertion, that are so biogically compatible.
You are incredible lucky if you find one suitable organ donor, if you can only chose from 100 people. This is evidence for my a point of view not yours.
You should keep in mind that we are dealing with a medical technology base far superior to our own, therefore blood type may not be the big problem it is today.

Having said that, and since I have not seen the episode in question for some time, I'll drop that issue.
Do you believe that every human is a suitable organ donor for another human?

Your assertion fails not mine.
I was incorrect by forgetting to include the possibility of blood type as a factor. I'll have to drop that issue until I see further evidence favoring my viewpoint and/or again reveiwing the episode in question.

However, the entire point of the discussion was whether or not Borg nanoprobes can target and assimilate non humanoid blood cells. Species 8472 is proof of this. We see a member of Species 8472 assimilated by the Docter's midified nanoprobes (ref STVOY "In the Flesh"). This was a real assimilation, not the explosive reaction we saw before. We clearly saw metallic strips(typical of Borg assimilation) appearing all over the Species 8472's body.
Howedar
Emperor's Thumb
Posts: 12472
Joined: 2002-07-03 05:06pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Howedar »

More than just blood types, it is apparent that the Romulan could not even make use of human blood expander products and the like (since IIRC the Romulan needed short-term assistance and nothing more). This means their blood must be vastly different. And it should be, since Vulcan (and therefore Romulan) blood is green, and therefore does not make use of normal hemoglobin and such.
Howedar is no longer here. Need to talk to him? Talk to Pick.
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Howedar wrote:More than just blood types, it is apparent that the Romulan could not even make use of human blood expander products and the like (since IIRC the Romulan needed short-term assistance and nothing more).
I believe that was the case, but I cannot reliable confirm it.
This means their blood must be vastly different. And it should be, since Vulcan (and therefore Romulan) blood is green, and therefore does not make use of normal hemoglobin and such.
I suspected blood color may have a been a factor in hinting at significant differences myself, but my lack of expertise in said field refrained me from mentioning so. After all, if I'm not mistaken, all mammals on Earth have red blood cells. Differences in color, like Klingon purple, or Romulan/Vulcan green would seem to imply some very significant differences.

Additionally, physcial makeup between species differs vastly as well. I recall Klingons being mentioned as having two stomachs, and an issue was brought up once with Spock about his heart not being where it is in a human being(was an attempt to imply Spock was a devil-like creature if I'm not mistken).

Since we know Borg nanoprobes can target and assimilate all listed species here, it seems to be a safe conclusion that Borg nanoprobes would not have difficulty in targetting and assimilating the blood cells of a dog.
User avatar
Gil Hamilton
Tipsy Space Birdie
Posts: 12962
Joined: 2002-07-04 05:47pm
Contact:

Post by Gil Hamilton »

Robert Walper wrote:That would strike me as a likely scenario. But simply being used for pleasure doesn't imply she was impregnanted without artificial assistance. We do know that a pure human and pure Klingon cannot procreate without plenty of artificial assistance. It may be the same with Rolumans and humans. I don't think Sela is adaquate evidence to argue either side effectively.
First of all, lots of species that you wouldn't think could breed in StarTrek can and do. Cardassians and Bajorians for example, with Gul Dukat's daughter -- which Dukat would have been courtmartialed if anyone found out about, by the way -- happened by accident. I doubt the Romulan officer is going risk his career just to have a kid with a sex toy he captured in battle. In fact, the details heavily imply that she was an accident herself. Therefore, we know for a fact that Romulans (and therefore Vulcans) are biologically human.

Secondly, even with fertility aids, two species cannot breed together and produce a viable offspring by definition of what a species is. K'helyr was the product of a union between a human and a Klingon, meaning that she should be a mule, yet she had Alexander with Worf accidentally on the first shot while having the old slap and holotickle. Without the aid of a fertility doctor. That doesn't just stretch the idea that they are alien species, it completely breaks it.
"Show me an angel and I will paint you one." - Gustav Courbet

"Quetzalcoatl, plumed serpent of the Aztecs... you are a pussy." - Stephen Colbert

"Really, I'm jealous of how much smarter than me he is. I'm not an expert on anything and he's an expert on things he knows nothing about." - Me, concerning a bullshitter
Howedar
Emperor's Thumb
Posts: 12472
Joined: 2002-07-03 05:06pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Howedar »

On the other hand, we've got the wrong-colored blood. If you don't have any hemoglobin in your blood you're sure as fuck not human. We know that Vulcan/Romulan blood must operate on different chemistry than human blood.


I don't see any way to rationalize this.
Howedar is no longer here. Need to talk to him? Talk to Pick.
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Howedar wrote:On the other hand, we've got the wrong-colored blood. If you don't have any hemoglobin in your blood you're sure as fuck not human. We know that Vulcan/Romulan blood must operate on different chemistry than human blood.


I don't see any way to rationalize this.
Well, we do know that in Trek, a vast quantity of the humanoid races, like Humans, Klingons, Rolumans and Cardassians were "seeded" by some "original" race that determined the Milky Way devoid of life eons ago.

My conclusion is that they are different races, but some of them can and do breed successfully. I just hang it up there with other Trek "Not scientifcally valid, but it's there anyhow" conclusions. Kinda like warp drive, phasers, transporters, etc, etc.

In this case I'd just suggest suspending disbelief as the only viable option and leaving it at that.
Howedar
Emperor's Thumb
Posts: 12472
Joined: 2002-07-03 05:06pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Howedar »

We can't suspend disbelief, Robert. We have incontrivertable evidence that humans and Klingons are the same species. On the other hand, we can be 100% certain that they are not the same species, because parts of their body simply work completely differently.
Howedar is no longer here. Need to talk to him? Talk to Pick.
User avatar
Luzifer's right hand
Jedi Master
Posts: 1417
Joined: 2003-11-30 01:45pm
Location: Austria

Post by Luzifer's right hand »

On the other hand, we've got the wrong-colored blood. If you don't have any hemoglobin in your blood you're sure as fuck not human. We know that Vulcan/Romulan blood must operate on different chemistry than human blood.
Not necessarily
Human blood, like that of all mammals and birds, is red because of a cocktail of iron-containing pigments, including hemoglobins (red), myoglobins (red), chlorocruorins (green), and haemerythrins (violet).

Haemocyanin (blue) contains copper not iron(eg. Horseshoe crabs, about 25% as efficient an oxygen carrier as hemoglobin)
The blood of the humble sea cucumbers is yellow-green and based on vanadium.

But it's time to concede defeat.
I forgot about the damn green blood, romulan blood cells could use only chlorocruorins of course, but that's unlikely(it's like Haemocyanin only about 25% as efficient an oxygen carrier as hemoglobi)

But there is still the probelm with breeding:
Living organisms do not have the ability to swap one respiratory pigment for another. But Even if it were possible to change pigments, the required physiological adjustments would probably be so far-reaching that the organism would no longer qualify as the same species.

::sigh:: I hate the inconstancies in Star Trek.


blood substitute in the real word:
Only one oxygen-carrying blood substitute has ever been approved afaik. That was Fluosol, a perfluorocarbon additive. Unfortunately, Fluosol was a frozen, two-part drug that had to be thawed and mixed immediately prior to use, and in large doses it required patients to breathe pure oxygen (potentially toxic) for the weeks it took their natural blood supply to recover. Meanwhile, doctors had to keep pumping the stuff in every 12 hours or the patient(tested on 13.000 patients) would die. However, this product was too unstable for use. (This blood substitute is green afaik)

Oxygen and CO2 can be dissolved directly into droplets of liquid perfluorocarbon, which holds and releases the two gases about as efficiently as hemoglobin does; when oxygenated, this liquid is even breathable(btw: the author of "the abyss" used it). However, produces side effects, from toxicity to allergies to exhaling an ozone-depleting gas.

Another approach is to weld(with ultrasound) roughly 1 million hemoglobin molecules into 2-micron hollow-core microspheres that carry 50% more oxygen per unit volume than natural red cells; the product, which remains 80% effective after 6 months' storage, it is in preliminary animal and human trials afaik.
You should keep in mind that we are dealing with a medical technology base far superior to our own, therefore blood type may not be the big problem it is today
I think our medical technology will outflank the technology showed in Star Trek in the near future. (Except for instant heal gadgets, but they are fantasy not "science" fiction imho).

and I apologize for my english. ;)
I asked The Lord, "Why hath thou forsaken me?" And He spoke unto me saying, "j00 R n00b 4 3VR", And I was like "stfu -_-;;"
Howedar
Emperor's Thumb
Posts: 12472
Joined: 2002-07-03 05:06pm
Location: St. Paul, MN

Post by Howedar »

Simple blood volume may have been enough. I don't know, I've not seen the episode since I was about nine.
Howedar is no longer here. Need to talk to him? Talk to Pick.
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Luzifer's right hand wrote:
On the other hand, we've got the wrong-colored blood. If you don't have any hemoglobin in your blood you're sure as fuck not human. We know that Vulcan/Romulan blood must operate on different chemistry than human blood.
Not necessarily
Human blood, like that of all mammals and birds, is red because of a cocktail of iron-containing pigments, including hemoglobins (red), myoglobins (red), chlorocruorins (green), and haemerythrins (violet).

Haemocyanin (blue) contains copper not iron(eg. Horseshoe crabs, about 25% as efficient an oxygen carrier as hemoglobin)
The blood of the humble sea cucumbers is yellow-green and based on vanadium.

But it's time to concede defeat.
I forgot about the damn green blood, romulan blood cells could use only chlorocruorins of course, but that's unlikely(it's like Haemocyanin only about 25% as efficient an oxygen carrier as hemoglobi)

But there is still the probelm with breeding:
Living organisms do not have the ability to swap one respiratory pigment for another. But Even if it were possible to change pigments, the required physiological adjustments would probably be so far-reaching that the organism would no longer qualify as the same species.

::sigh:: I hate the inconstancies in Star Trek.
Don't we all! :wink:
blood substitute in the real word:
Only one oxygen-carrying blood substitute has ever been approved afaik. That was Fluosol, a perfluorocarbon additive. Unfortunately, Fluosol was a frozen, two-part drug that had to be thawed and mixed immediately prior to use, and in large doses it required patients to breathe pure oxygen (potentially toxic) for the weeks it took their natural blood supply to recover. Meanwhile, doctors had to keep pumping the stuff in every 12 hours or the patient(tested on 13.000 patients) would die. However, this product was too unstable for use. (This blood substitute is green afaik)

Oxygen and CO2 can be dissolved directly into droplets of liquid perfluorocarbon, which holds and releases the two gases about as efficiently as hemoglobin does; when oxygenated, this liquid is even breathable(btw: the author of "the abyss" used it). However, produces side effects, from toxicity to allergies to exhaling an ozone-depleting gas.

Another approach is to weld(with ultrasound) roughly 1 million hemoglobin molecules into 2-micron hollow-core microspheres that carry 50% more oxygen per unit volume than natural red cells; the product, which remains 80% effective after 6 months' storage, it is in preliminary animal and human trials afaik.
You should keep in mind that we are dealing with a medical technology base far superior to our own, therefore blood type may not be the big problem it is today
I think our medical technology will outflank the technology showed in Star Trek in the near future. (Except for instant heal gadgets, but they are fantasy not "science" fiction imho).
True enough. The point being is if there are some very conflicting circumstances, in this case blood differences and inter species breeding, the best conclusion IMO is to stick it to the sci'fi's superior medical capabilities.
and I apologize for my english. ;)
Actually, I suppose I owe you an apology for that comment. Referring to my entry into the infamous "Hate Mail" page, my english isn't exactly in the best of forms either. :lol:
User avatar
Shrykull
Jedi Master
Posts: 1270
Joined: 2002-07-05 09:11pm

Post by Shrykull »

To further support your and my assertion, Seven of Nine explicitly stated that the Borg Collective is not interested in assimilating inferior forms of life. Seven of Nine stated that a Raven is considered such a lifeform (ref STVOY "Raven").
Why wouldn't they want to assimilate a changeling though? Shapeshifting would be very useful to them. And the ability to move at warp through space without a ship (like Laas did) And even to become fire like Laas did.





The differences in immune systems and biology is a Red Herring. Using this arguement would be implying thousands of races assimilated by the Borg have identical immune systems and biological, when we know significant differences exist between just vulcans, humans, klingons, etc, etc. Not to mention other more distant races in the Delta Quadrant, like the Hirogen, etc.
First of all, just how big are nanoprobes? The name implies they are nanometers large (billionths of a meter) But blood cells are way larger than that. Changelings don't have blood, and it's never been clear what exactly happens when they shift to another shape or state of matter (like Laas becoming fog or the founders clouds) We know that the material they are made of can be used to make humanoid organs (When Bashir borrowed some from Odo) And we've heard of thier "bio-molecular structure" in the die is cast and thier "morphogenic matrix" in the Laas ep and another episode. The nanoprobes would first have to gain control of thier mind, and subjugate it, and we what don't know constitutes one for a changeling, for all we know they could be one huge organ. Why is it odo had no sense of smell or taste, but did have "eyes" and "ears" that could see and hear?

And the killing blow is that Species 8472 blood cells were idenitifiable by Borg nanoprobes. Once the nanoprobes were modified to escape detection by the Species 8472 immune system, they had no problems targetting and attacking said blood cells. And Species 8472 is a non humanoid organism. I consider the case closed.
Did the collective know that this attempt to destroy the cells worked? I don't remember the specifics, just that the doctor modified them to destroy the cells infecting Harry Kim, and there was a collaboration of Seven, Tuvok and Janeway. If the collective found out how to get them to evade 8472's immune system and get to the blood cells, then why didn't they ever try assimilating that way?
Robert Walper
Dishonest Resident Borg Fan-Whore
Posts: 4206
Joined: 2002-08-08 03:56am
Location: Calgary, Alberta, Canada

Post by Robert Walper »

Shrykull wrote:
To further support your and my assertion, Seven of Nine explicitly stated that the Borg Collective is not interested in assimilating inferior forms of life. Seven of Nine stated that a Raven is considered such a lifeform (ref STVOY "Raven").
Why wouldn't they want to assimilate a changeling though?
What makes the Borg's lack of interest in assimilating birds evidence they would not want to assimilate changelings? A changeling in the form of a bird may fool them, but an being which they have identified as a changeling would undoubtedly interest them very much.
Shapeshifting would be very useful to them.
Undoubtably.
And the ability to move at warp through space without a ship (like Laas did)
This suggests changelings may utilize subspace properties, which would also hint at how they can effectively "change" their mass, like Odo turning into a rat.
And even to become fire like Laas did.
Correction...immitating fire. There's no reason to assume Laas in fact "became" fire in every conceivable sense. We do know of living creatures(fireflies) that can produce light. The best conclusion seems to me is that Founders can either produce or possess cells capable of the same feat(unless I'm misunderstanding the chemical process fireflies utilize).
The differences in immune systems and biology is a Red Herring. Using this arguement would be implying thousands of races assimilated by the Borg have identical immune systems and biological, when we know significant differences exist between just vulcans, humans, klingons, etc, etc. Not to mention other more distant races in the Delta Quadrant, like the Hirogen, etc.
First of all, just how big are nanoprobes?
They are signifcantly bigger than blood cells. They do not enter the living cells, they attach to them. Visuals from Voyager's medical bay showed this quite clearly. I can supply a perfect screenshot if required as proof.
The name implies they are nanometers large (billionths of a meter) But blood cells are way larger than that.
Terminology is overruled by visual evidence. A sandwhich has the term "sand" in it; does not mean sand is part of a sandwhich though. :wink:
Changelings don't have blood,
Blood isn't required for nanoprobes to assimilate something. Unless someone were to assert computer consoles and technology that have been infected and assimilated by nanoprobes have "blood". :wink:
and it's never been clear what exactly happens when they shift to another shape or state of matter (like Laas becoming fog or the founders clouds) We know that the material they are made of can be used to make humanoid organs (When Bashir borrowed some from Odo) And we've heard of thier "bio-molecular structure" in the die is cast and thier "morphogenic matrix" in the Laas ep and another episode. The nanoprobes would first have to gain control of thier mind, and subjugate it,
Actually, mind control isn't required for nanoprobes to do their work. You can see this in Star Trek: First Contact. A Enterprise security officer is injected with nanoprobes, which are clearly assimilating him to a significant degree, despite him still possessing free will to beg Captain Picard for help.
and we what don't know constitutes one for a changeling, for all we know they could be one huge organ. Why is it odo had no sense of smell or taste, but did have "eyes" and "ears" that could see and hear?
This is geting more into the nature and makeup of changelings. Difficult to determine by myself anyhow.

The overall point being is that Borg nanoprobes have canonly been witnessed to assimilated organic and non organic targets. Given that versatility, I don't consider it highly likely that changelings would be effectively resistant against Borg nanoprobes, particularily in the light of Starfleet engineers being capable of creating a disease that works on them quite well.
And the killing blow is that Species 8472 blood cells were idenitifiable by Borg nanoprobes. Once the nanoprobes were modified to escape detection by the Species 8472 immune system, they had no problems targetting and attacking said blood cells. And Species 8472 is a non humanoid organism. I consider the case closed.
Did the collective know that this attempt to destroy the cells worked?
Obviously, since they knew why Species 8472 retreated from their territory.
I don't remember the specifics, just that the doctor modified them to destroy the cells infecting Harry Kim, and there was a collaboration of Seven, Tuvok and Janeway.
Which resulted in production of Borg nanoprobes, by the Voyager's doctor, which then were employed by Voyager's torpedo arsenal.
If the collective found out how to get them to evade 8472's immune system and get to the blood cells,
The Voyager doctor actually figured that out. And the Voyager crew kept the Borg from obtaining or learning how it had been done.
then why didn't they ever try assimilating that way?
See above. :)
User avatar
Shrykull
Jedi Master
Posts: 1270
Joined: 2002-07-05 09:11pm

Post by Shrykull »

This suggests changelings may utilize subspace properties, which would also hint at how they can effectively "change" their mass, like Odo turning into a rat.
When Robert Moore used to answer questions on AOL I asked him a few about changelings, I would have to go through the archive to find it. he said that Odo's communicator goes into subspace when he reverts to liquid form, and that it was only Odo that needed revert to liquid form every so often, the founders know more about shapeshifting (so did Laas) so perhaps when they shapeshift they could actually become "real solids" (humanoids, though I think that's bad terminology, there are solids that aren't humanoids, like the Horta, Kelvins who is thier true forms are twice a humanoid's height, maybe 8472, but they were bipedal) like Odo did temporarily, or who knows, maybe it takes the whole great link or some at least several changelings to perform this feat on someone
And even to become fire like Laas did.
Correction...immitating fire. There's no reason to assume Laas in fact "became" fire in every conceivable sense. We do know of living creatures(fireflies) that can produce light. The best conclusion seems to me is that Founders can either produce or possess cells capable of the same feat(unless I'm misunderstanding the chemical process fireflies utilize).
I doubt they even have cells, though it has been stated they have DNA, but I don't see how they could, when he became a gas, the molecules are independant of each other, how could the genes hope to stay together through such drastic changes, they don't need to eat, so perhaps thier enzymes never need to be replaced (we don't know how they get thier energy either, hmm perhaps it comes from subspace?)
The differences in immune systems and biology is a Red Herring. Using this arguement would be implying thousands of races assimilated by the Borg have identical immune systems and biological, when we know significant differences exist between just vulcans, humans, klingons, etc, etc. Not to mention other more distant races in the Delta Quadrant, like the Hirogen, etc.
First of all, just how big are nanoprobes?
They are signifcantly bigger than blood cells. They do not enter the living cells, they attach to them. Visuals from Voyager's medical bay showed this quite clearly. I can supply a perfect screenshot if required as proof.


Yes, I would, if you could PM me about it. And how did you get it, did you hook a tv to your computer, then catch it on your screen? I just got snag-it, used to have a TV card.
The name implies they are nanometers large (billionths of a meter) But blood cells are way larger than that.
Terminology is overruled by visual evidence. A sandwhich has the term "sand" in it; does not mean sand is part of a sandwhich though. :wink:
Who said I agreed with it, I just said "the name implies"
Changelings don't have blood,
Blood isn't required for nanoprobes to assimilate something. Unless someone were to assert computer consoles and technology that have been infected and assimilated by nanoprobes have "blood". :wink:
Could you be more specific? We know they assimilate through the blood, I'm not sure how the nanoprobes take control of a computer, unless they could "hack" it and get the computer to send whatever signals they want it to send, but like I said more specifically what do the nanoprobes do the hardware, buses, processor, er....actually scratch that, we're dealing with a quantum computer now, and they would need to be able to control sub-atomic particles, oh boy. :wink:
and it's never been clear what exactly happens when they shift to another shape or state of matter (like Laas becoming fog or the founders clouds) We know that the material they are made of can be used to make humanoid organs (When Bashir borrowed some from Odo) And we've heard of thier "bio-molecular structure" in the die is cast and thier "morphogenic matrix" in the Laas ep and another episode. The nanoprobes would first have to gain control of thier mind, and subjugate it,
Actually, mind control isn't required for nanoprobes to do their work.

who said it was? But it is required for them to controlled by the collective.
You can see this in Star Trek: First Contact. A Enterprise security officer is injected with nanoprobes, which are clearly assimilating him to a significant degree, despite him still possessing free will to beg Captain Picard for help.
So? The nanoprobes hadn't gotten all over his brain yet, and made him a slave.
and we what don't know constitutes one for a changeling, for all we know they could be one huge organ. Why is it odo had no sense of smell or taste, but did have "eyes" and "ears" that could see and hear?
This is geting more into the nature and makeup of changelings. Difficult to determine by myself anyhow.

The overall point being is that Borg nanoprobes have canonly been witnessed to assimilated organic and non organic targets. Given that versatility, I don't consider it highly likely that changelings would be effectively resistant against Borg nanoprobes, particularily in the light of Starfleet engineers being capable of creating a disease that works on them quite well.
The nanos would probably just float around in the goo and not be able to attach to anything since it is too small. I still need more specific info like how they control machines and assimilate/subjugate through the blood, getting control of thier mind and making them obey is the first order of business.

There must be something about changelings that's constant, no matter what form they take, if the entire great link couldn't cure it, the info is inconsistant.





The Voyager doctor actually figured that out. And the Voyager crew kept the Borg from obtaining or learning how it had been done.
Um, wasn't Seven part of the group, and knew while still being in the collective?
Post Reply