Page 1 of 1

Discovery question

Posted: 2019-09-26 08:41pm
by WhiteLion
In Star Trek Discovery they really thought outside the box by creating the spore engine. At first I thought it was a mistake, but then I saw his use of war, when they performed jumps in rapid succession around the enemy ship. It was almost as if he were teleporting. On a tactical level it is an enormous advantage, it means appearing and launching a torpedo and disappearing before being attacked, and reappearing at another point and attacking again, and so on until the destruction of the ship ... or of the connected doctor's nervous system to drive a spore :)

However nice thought tactic, what do you think?

Re: Discovery question

Posted: 2019-09-27 02:10pm
by Lord Revan
There's some major issues with mycelial drive. "slowly kills the navigator" or "might in end up in a different time or universe" is a rather major problem wouldn't you say so.

Battle of Pahvo nearly killed Stamets thru exessive stress from doing so many jumps.

Re: Discovery question

Posted: 2019-09-27 07:33pm
by WhiteLion
Yes you are right, and you agree with me. It is an imperfect technology, not usable in series but only as a unique case to make Discovery more OP

Re: Discovery question

Posted: 2019-09-28 03:48pm
by Lord Revan
WhiteLion wrote: 2019-09-27 07:33pm Yes you are right, and you agree with me. It is an imperfect technology, not usable in series but only as a unique case to make Discovery more OP
Yes if by Discovery you mean the Starship USS Discovery (NCC-1031) and even then it is of very, very limited use, it isn't just imperfect, it's impractical for long time use.

The stress of long term use burns out the navigators and without a proper navigator you can't promise you'll end where and when you want, which is a rather major issue especially if there's options.

EDIT:If there hadn't been a major war they were loosing badly, I doubt the Federation would have OKed the use of mycelial drive even at testing purposes.

Re: Discovery question

Posted: 2019-09-30 06:36am
by WhiteLion
Today's navigators no longer have the fiber of the past, they fall like flies after a few jumps :)

Seriously, yes, it's true, it's a nice find to make the series interesting, but it's too risky for a ship and navigator.