StarDestroyer.Net BBS

Right, look, it's like this: You admit that there is a shield on Hoth, right? Not a planetary shield, just a shield on a planet, whatever the difference is supposed to be. From ROTJ we know that a single shield generator on Endor (or complex of generators, point stands) can cover a >160km diameter ...

I'm sorry, you just claimed every last one of them did. But if we assume for the time being that was the result of you being too stupid to properly use the English language (which let's face it, it was) how about those planets being seriously affected in ways that could've been prevented by them ge...

No I did not. I have repeatedly quoted exactly what you said and pointed out your error. You have repeatedly tried to weasel out of it by saying, variously, that I missread you, or that it "wasn't what I meant to say" or that I missquoted you which I clearly have not done. we talked about...

Maybe they don't trust the Empire. I doubt that the Death Star was the first time the Empire used genocide to scare people into staying in line. Maybe the major cost is the installation, but upkeep is comparatively cheap, so there is no incentive to remove it. Maybe removing the shield generators i...

some really great responses but i just want to know Alderaan has always been a focal point for resistance against the Empire. Vader himself stated that Alderaan was a hotbed for rebellious sentiment. where is your Canon source? That's the dumbest thing I've heard you say so far...and that's saying s...

Thank you for stating that all of those planets did have a planetary shield (double negatives are a bitch). wow there are some issues with people on this board. Sure claim that as a victory for you But can you tell me why a single planet on that list doesn't have a planetary shield? and i'm heading...

I took exactly what you had said and pointed out the obvious error. That is a quote YOU didn't take exactly what i fucking wrote!!!! You misquoted me! And yes, we did make a point about the units. You said there was no proof they used the metric system, so we provided evidence and quotes that they ...

Let's see...we have a civil war going on with tens of thousands of systems if not more under attack, why would anybody want a defense mechanism that makes it if not impossible then at the very least really hard for any opposing force to hurt your planet. 19 years ago there was a civil war. edit yea...

You of all people are quibbling over semantics? Answer the fucking point . You said something dumb, I called you out on it, you lied about what you'd said. Drop this linguistic bullshit and address the point. I'd also note that you've completely stopped answering Batman's posts about the area cover...

i dont' think they ever attacked Alderaan Are you saying that Alderaan wouldn't want a shield until after they get attacked ? If so, why ? If not, please clarify what you actually meant. Maybe they were attacked off screen. Maybe they weren't attacked because they had a shield strong enough that an...

No, I quoted you and demonstrated your error. You're trying to weasel out of it. Ok wtf do you really not understand what a quote is? because writting what you "think" i wrote is not a quote. Tell me what you think a quote is yes I did missread what he wrote but there is no canon evidence...

No, I quoted you and demonstrated your error. You're trying to weasel out of it. Ok wtf do you really not understand what a quote is? because writting what you "think" i wrote is not a quote. Tell me what you think a quote is yes I did missread what he wrote but there is no canon evidence...

"some elements that are oxidents which create their own oxygen." That's what you said, the meaning is the same as "all the oxygen released by other elements," only the original version you wrote is even dumber. You are grasping at very thin straws here. no you moron that's not a...

Yeah. Right. What? Because for any planet that can afford to, it's an incredibly useful precaution to have? well that's just it protection from what? They are a core world, a peaceful world that has no weapons and are an important part of the Imperial senate. So why would they need it? We never see...

Oh I dunno, maybe from the Imperials who were forced to send a fucking Death Star to blow it up? that's the rulling government. The ones that are protecting them. The Empire never invaded Allderaan why would they think that it would? EDIT Oh wait this is even better you're trying to say that they h...

http://cdn04.cdn.justjaredjr.com/wp-content/uploads/headlines/2014/04/daisy-ridley-john-boyega-star-wars.jpg Daisy Ridley and John Boyega http://cdn01.thewrap.com/images/2013/11/Driver-News-618x400.jpg Adam Driver http://ia.media-imdb.com/images/M/MV5BMTQ2ODE2NDQ5OF5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwOTU3OTM1OQ@@._V...

I have always quoted you directly. bullshit Show me where i said and all the oxygen released by other elements. You claimed I said that Remember a huge planet just exploded lots of oxygen and other elements some elements that are oxidents which create their own oxygen when placed in high thermal si...

Yeah. Right. What? Because for any planet that can afford to, it's an incredibly useful precaution to have? well that's just it protection from what? They are a core world, a peaceful world that has no weapons and are an important part of the Imperial senate. So why would they need it? We never see...

Eternal_Freedom wrote:I have always quoted you directly.

bullshit

Show me where i said

and all the oxygen released by other elements.

You claimed I said that

I pointed out your error, you responded by saying I misread you and supported this by only quoting part of your statement, ignoring the part containing the error. well you didn't point out my error. You misquoted me and then i fixed what you missquoted Here is my response to your initial statement:...

actually that is a very good question.

Why would Alderaan have a Planetary shield?

Eternal_Freedom wrote:I pointed out your error, you responded by saying I misread you and supported this by only quoting part of your statement, ignoring the part containing the error.

well you didn't point out my error. You misquoted me and then i fixed what you missquoted

Borgholio wrote:

I find it weird on these boards that people latch on to one thing as if that validates everything they said.

It validates the idea that you have no clue what you're talking about. If you're going to quote numbers then for fucks sake quote realistic numbers.

... do you not know what quote means?

Once again you are only quoting part of your statement, ignoring the part with the error! "Remember a huge planet just exploded lots of oxygen and other elements some elements that are oxidants which create their own oxygen when placed in high thermal situations." You clearly state that &...

Except you suggested one or two square miles. That's an area , not a distance . And given that area yeah, I'm very much afraid my calculations are correct-if we assume the Imps landed immediately outside your 2 square mile shield, yes, they were less then a kilometre from the rebel base. fine make ...