Really? That explains allot about your tendency to make stuff up and pull from non-canon sources if you believe that.
Hey I don't think I was talking to you but whatever. Ouch. I stick with canon as much as I can. Sometimes I fall back on logic. Actually it's you guys who violate canon when you pretty much assume 90% of what is said on star trek isn't factual when is suits your purpose. I give quotes and provide where they come from so people can verify what i'm telling them. I don't see much of that in return.
Sorry but evidence MUST be canon.
hmm... NO. It says so here
http://www.stardestroyer.net/Empire/Misc/Canon.html
I'm sure that's the way certain people like it because star wars canon is broad and star trek canon is narrow. As long as the terms of what is considered canon in the debate are agreed upon, it's okay to broaden or restrict canon however one wishes. This hasn't been done. A real treky wouldn't concede defeat over a technicality found in a star wars reference guide, footnote, comic book, video game, etc... The whole point is to convince the other person you're right and they're wrong. Think of it as both parties defining canon between themselves and agreeing to use what they defined. In that sense, once canon is defined, the evidence MUST be "canon" as they agree for it to be defined.
I'll work within the rules of canon here just so I don't hear whineing about it but if you really think it's a requirement you're sadly mistaken.
It doesn't have to be that way. I've been to debate boards that outlaw ICS for example. You really didn't know this?
The Borg have consistently Ignored heavily armed parties going through their territory, the only time they ever attack without provocation is the if they enter the Central Plexus or similar area, which a station or ship can be destroyed without going anywhere near.
That's the point. It was being proposed that they'd take out the main reactor with a bomb. They wouldn't be allowed there without being resisted. The death star has shields anyway. They wouldn't get inside easily. A combination of a direct assault and covert op mission would be needed from the sounds of it.
Considering Blasters fire hot plasma with incoherent energy and the Borg can't handle cold plasma or coherent energy that they haven't matched frequencies with. That would be a no. Not to mention the fact that Imperials use kinetic weaponry and such as well. Which the Borg have likewise shown a weakness to.
This is kinda along the same lines I was talking about before. It's ok to mention your sources here and explain why you think it is so. Warsies tends to downgrade how powerful star trek weapons actually are. Here's some examples:
star trek has countless canon proof that people get vaporized from phaser fire making it more powerful than blasters. It is something supported by tons of dialogue and certain visuals such as vapor appearing afterward. Because of certain scientific restrictions, the visuals are picked apart and the energy output of st weapons is downgraded. Phasers are called chain reaction weapons as a result even if countless dialogue also states they are directed energy weapons.
A star trek fan will tell you the borg will adapt to a blaster just like they do a phaser. The destructive firepower of a blaster is less impressive than a phaser. If a borg can adapt to a phaser, it can adapt to a blaser. A star trek / star wars writer wouldn't permit you to make weapons that the borg cannot adapt to.
Your assumption about kinetic weapons and the borg's ability to adapt to them is stupid. Away teams would have beamed over to borg vessels with machine guns if it were the case on the star trek series. If Worf can make a portable force field with his communicator on the holodeck to protect himself from bullets ("a fistful of datas"), I think the borg would do it too. Call me crazy.
Also Borg have never used anything resembling a land mine or anything of the sort. Since they are notorious in their lack of tactics and ingenuity, we can safely rule that possibility out.
Most likely this collective in star wars won't behave like the collective from star trek since they are no doubt seperated from the collective from star trek. The hive mind is that of a star wars mentality. If the borg assimilated the knowledge of an EMP grenade and had access to them, they would at least consider using them if they knew it would counteract resistence from artificial beings. It doesn't matter if they never used them before. No doubt they've assimilated people from star wars. The collective minds of the officers from the star wars galaxy would be thinking to use the EMP grenades then that's what they use.
You're looking for evidence of Borg transporting someone who is already on their ship to another section of their ship, like a brig/assimilation chamber, or hell even out into space.
We won't find much considering most races don't board borg vessels.
In episode "Collective". Chakotay, Nelix, and Tom woke up in an assimilation chamber. They were no doubt beamed in there from the shuttle which was inside the cube docked with it. When Mezoti caught Kim trying to sabotosh the shield generator on a borg cube, we don't see him again until later where he is in another area of the ship and unconscious. I don't Kim would have surrendered to the girl. Most likely she overpowered him somehow. Probably by activating a forcefield near him the way she did with Tom. I doubt she dragged him all the way to another section of the ship. We know that the ship had transporter capability since 7 of 9 beamed the infant drone to voyager.
That's about all I have right now. Hopefully that triggers your common sense that if the borg have transporter capability, they will use it if it's the most efficient thing to do. To me it's just common sense not to assume they wouldn't.