Debating Health Care (Long OP)

Get advice, tips, or help with science or religion debates that you are currently participating in.

Moderator: Alyrium Denryle

Dillon
Rabid Monkey
Posts: 1017
Joined: 2002-07-03 09:00am
Location: Toronto, Canada

Re: Debating Health Care (Long OP)

Post by Dillon »

Prannon wrote:I'm asking if they're gonna keep serving you if you don't pay and you keep coming, again and again and again. I had a friend whose mother had to go to the ER or clinics or somesuch regularly without insurance and no way to pay. I recall that she was eventually told not to come back again. It's an anecdote, but it puts me in doubt of his statement.
Maybe he's right and maybe you're right. But who cares? Emergency room treatment is hardly the only aspect of essential health care. There is chronic care as The Spartan pointed out, there are annual check ups, consultation with specialists, etc...
The argument he and I have had is actually really long. He argues that UHC won't work in the US because it's too different from other countries. He implies that it's too big, has too many people, can't pay for it, has an eroding economy, and culturally it isn't acceptable because it's SOCIALISM and comparable to Russia, China, Venezeula, Cuba, and he lists Poland for some reason. He believes that the better solution is to reign in insurance companies through strict regulations and serious oversight. He also derides me as being ignorant and not understanding how the political system works, and implies that I didn't learn a thing at college.
Ahh, the "America is unique" argument. Point out that Americans pay roughly double per person for health care compared to nations with socialized health care like Canada, the UK, Germany, etc... If anything, they can't afford not to adopt UHC.
I'm arguing that even though quality of care is lower in places like Canada and the UK, it's more accessible. I'm also arguing that Korean Public Health Care is better because it's more accessible, even if it's comparitively lousy (he cites a friend of his who has an injured hand, who's been to several doctors, and can't get it fixed). I've cited Life Expectancy figures from the CIA World Factbook, polls from this article, and the article from Bill Moyer's interview with Wendell Potter.
You can also hit him the the World Health Report, the Perinatal Mortality Rate and the Under Five Mortality Rate. The fact that U.S. seems to do poorly on all these statistics, relative to nations with socialized health care who enjoy similar socio-economic prosperity (and indeed, some that are well below their level of economic prosperity, such as Cuba), would seem to indicate that American health care simply isn't doing as good a job at saving lives as UHC systems are.
I still believe that UHC is the better option to solving this whole mess. Heavily regulating the insurance industry is almost the same as creating a public option anyway, based on my limited understanding of how this stuff works. His argument that the uninsured can just go to the ER for treatment made me trip up though. I argued that one can't get specialized treatment at the ER. He dismissed that saying that virtually no GP offers specialized treatment. In hindsight, that wasn't really a rebuttal. You need insurance to see a specialist for things like cancer.
GPs will refer you to specialists under UHC if necessary.
User avatar
Razorgeist
Youngling
Posts: 83
Joined: 2009-10-29 06:30am

Re: Debating Health Care (Long OP)

Post by Razorgeist »

A coworker sent me this video from congressman Mike Rogers.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G44NCvNDLfc

Im fairly certain that his whole shpeel about the cancer statistics has been debunked and I dont trust republicans by default but does anyone have any other refutations of what he says? I only ask because I know my coworker is gonna try and argue with me about it later.
"You have to believe in God before you can say there are things that man was not meant to know.
I don't think there's anything man wasn't meant to know. There are just some stupid things that people shouldn't do." - David Cronenberg


"Doesn't Rush Limbaugh remind you of one of those gay guys that like to lie in a tub while other guys pee on him?" - Bill Hicks
User avatar
PainRack
Emperor's Hand
Posts: 7580
Joined: 2002-07-07 03:03am
Location: Singapura

Re: Debating Health Care (Long OP)

Post by PainRack »

Regarding cancer, doesn't the whole War on Cancer with government funded research critical to America advantage in treating cancers.... the Dana Farbar, Mayo clinic and stuff....
Let him land on any Lyran world to taste firsthand the wrath of peace loving people thwarted by the myopic greed of a few miserly old farts- Katrina Steiner
Post Reply