Page 5 of 11

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-19 05:10pm
by Crossroads Inc.
Skywalker_T-65 wrote:You know, is it just me or does the map seem crowded even without a large chunk of the people who are playing? Wasn't there 30 or so nations (counting the micronations)? That could become a problem depending on the remaining nations size (I know Arcadia and the SPACE VIKINGS aren't a problem being 8 sectors put together...)
Agreed, We may end up needing a much bigger map. Lord knows many of the spots I want get snatched.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-19 05:27pm
by Simon_Jester
I'll look into it after compiling the next map iteration over the weekend.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-19 07:01pm
by White Haven
Eh, at last call there still vast swathes of space unused...more than enough room to densen things up. Densen? Whatever. Anyway, nations nearly eyeball-to-eyeball can be good for tension and HIGH-STAKES DIPLOMANCY! My early-warning network can see your fleets massing, man, back off or I'll preemptively defend the shit out of you!

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 08:43am
by Rabid
White Haven wrote:Eh, at last call there still vast swathes of space unused...more than enough room to densen things up. Densen? Whatever. Anyway, nations nearly eyeball-to-eyeball can be good for tension and HIGH-STAKES DIPLOMANCY! My early-warning network can see your fleets massing, man, back off or I'll preemptively defend the shit out of you!
"Mang, I'm only preparing an attack against those fucking pirates in the Shoals. Chill the fuck out !"

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 08:55am
by Simon_Jester
Umerians:

"Yeah, antipiracy! Do you want to come along? We're handing out free jetpacks..."

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:10am
by Rabid
*Fleija, Captain of the DN[Doxa's Navy] Gently Backstabbing You Escort-Cruiser of the Terminus Sector Fleet*

"Fuck yeah we do ! Raiders make good target practice, and I've got to train my apprentice ; the kid only has twenty years of experience in active duty so far."

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:13am
by Skywalker_T-65
'Sure, why not, we could use the practice. After all, we have the SPACE VIKINGS to deal with too' (Arcadian)

'You're just asking to get yourself shot now...' (Furling)

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:17am
by Simon_Jester
Let's carry this over to commentary, okay?

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:26am
by Imperial528
Does anyone have issues with this placement?

Image

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:29am
by Skywalker_T-65
I don't see a problem, though it does confirm my suspicion of the maps size (or lack thereof). It will be quite interesting once it starts though, with everyone clustered down there...

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:37am
by Rabid
It'd be cool if there was more people up there, cuz right now the Hub is a bit out of the way... :sadpanda:

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 10:45am
by Simon_Jester
Hm.

One: Charcoal gray is a bad color for a nation on a black map. I'll fix that in the next draft of the map.

Two: Cernans, you're a recent arrival from distant galactic space... but so are the Chamarrans. It seems a bit unlikely that you'd end up in almost the same place. They're coming from the next spiral arm out toward the rim; how about you coming in from the coreward side of the map and being near the 'top?'

Three: The Hub isn't as isolated as all that. Several nations placed themselves in that neighborhood since I made the last draft of the map a week ago. If I remake the map, it will look less desolate. Also, the Hub makes more sense as a trading nexus if it's actually some distance away from the nearest major powers- ships that reach the Hub have been traveling long enough it makes sense for them to stop there, and long enough that it makes sense to use the place as a trans-shipment point for goods. If there was a major power nestled right up against the Hub sector, then it would be hard to explain why the Hub hasn't been assimilated into that major power's control, and also hard to explain why the shipping traffic isn't stopping there. It makes it harder to answer the obvious question: "what's so special about the Hub, anyway?"

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 11:00am
by Rabid
Simon_Jester wrote:"what's so special about the Hub, anyway?"
Some of the best shipyards in the Known Galaxy (new merchant ship fabrication / old ships repair & retrofitting), and the constant fabrication of new civilian hulls of good performances & fabrication at affordable prices ;
Thousands of years as a merchant "nation" in its own right, which allow merchants from the whole galaxy to use the place as a meeting ground - there's a permanent Fair on Cradle where business-people from the whole Known Galaxy showcase their latest products ;
And relatively few questions asked as to what exactly you are shipping through there - just the minimum to know if it risk damaging the harbor's installations.

A bit like a Space-Venice, in short.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 11:00am
by Imperial528
I can switch it to a lighter gray, although it's your call color wise, I would just prefer a gray. And I think I will move it toward the top, that was my first choice but it seemed a bit isolated.

Also, while they are more recent arrivals then the older powers, they've been here for at least a few centuries. I haven't quite decided just how long, but it'd be more like "new, but the beginning is only remembered by the really old folks" instead of "Hey, remember when those guys showed up a few decades ago?" like it is with the Chammarans.

If anything the only reason why they would seem new is because outside of close neighbors they wouldn't have been really trying to contact anyone for a good chunk of their history.

How would this be:

Image

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 12:12pm
by Simon_Jester
Rabid wrote:
Simon_Jester wrote:"what's so special about the Hub, anyway?"
Some of the best shipyards in the Known Galaxy (new merchant ship fabrication / old ships repair & retrofitting), and the constant fabrication of new civilian hulls of good performances & fabrication at affordable prices ;
Thousands of years as a merchant "nation" in its own right, which allow merchants from the whole galaxy to use the place as a meeting ground - there's a permanent Fair on Cradle where business-people from the whole Known Galaxy showcase their latest products ;
And relatively few questions asked as to what exactly you are shipping through there - just the minimum to know if it risk damaging the harbor's installations.

A bit like a Space-Venice, in short.
Right, but the question is: why is the Hub where it is? Why is this specific place a sensible one for traders to stop, even if it's a little out of the shortest-path route to their destination?

People stopped in Venice to trade for specific reasons; Venice would not have become a major trading port if it didn't have a good location.

If there were competing major worlds near the Hub, it would detract from the Hub's status.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 01:12pm
by Rabid
Well, there's the theory that thousand and thousand of years back it was the commercial center of a vast Empire, which has faded away since then ; or that it was at the crossroad of vast empires which have fallen since then ? I dunno. Basically, I want to give the impression of a very old world, which may have seen brighter days sometime in its past, but which still maintain an important portion of its former glory.


If some people know the RPG "Fading Suns", my (really vague) inspiration for Cradle is Byzantium Secundus.


As to WHY do modern-day traders stop there... Well, I would see it in the same way as ports like Shangai or Hamburg : container ships unload containers, load containers, others ships load the previously unloaded containers after having unloaded their own, etc...
Sea-Trade these days use big ships, who travel on specific routes, and I'd tend to see Space-Trade doing the same : common goods don't go directly from point A to point B, they transit from place to place.
The Hub is a place where a good chunk of the Space-Trade routes in the Known Galaxy stops to load and unload goods.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 02:16pm
by Simon_Jester
Rabid wrote:Well, there's the theory that thousand and thousand of years back it was the commercial center of a vast Empire, which has faded away since then ; or that it was at the crossroad of vast empires which have fallen since then ? I dunno. Basically, I want to give the impression of a very old world, which may have seen brighter days sometime in its past, but which still maintain an important portion of its former glory.
Sure, I'm OK with that, though you may have to work out some of the details with our card-carrying elder races.
As to WHY do modern-day traders stop there... Well, I would see it in the same way as ports like Shangai or Hamburg : container ships unload containers, load containers, others ships load the previously unloaded containers after having unloaded their own, etc...
Sea-Trade these days use big ships, who travel on specific routes, and I'd tend to see Space-Trade doing the same : common goods don't go directly from point A to point B, they transit from place to place.
The Hub is a place where a good chunk of the Space-Trade routes in the Known Galaxy stops to load and unload goods.
Yes, this makes sense- but, that being the case, it really helps if it's a well-placed "container port" and the only such port within a long distance. If some major stellar nation made the investment to create a similar port a short distance away, it might threaten the Hub's primacy and status.

Which would be an interesting thing if we wanted to set it up, but I wouldn't think you'd want that imposed on you by default by, say, sticking a macronation capital sector right next door to the Hub.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 02:18pm
by Skywalker_T-65
Would I be one of said elder races? (or rather, the Furlings are)

If so, I'm perfectly fine with that view of the Hub.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:17pm
by Force Lord
I want my grid colors to be exactly the same as they were for SDNW4, that is, a dark hue of blue. No sense choosing black because the grids are black. :)

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:18pm
by Rabid
I hope no one here is colorblind ? :lol:

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:20pm
by Force Lord
You guys are...

*puts on Gay-Bans*

... seeing red.

YEEEEEEAAAAH

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:25pm
by Rabid
Force Lord wrote:Gay-Bans
Seriously, now ? :lol:

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:28pm
by Force Lord
Rabid wrote:
Force Lord wrote:Gay-Bans
Seriously, now ? :lol:
Let me explain, in the previous game there were sunglasses named exactly like that. It's not my idea.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:42pm
by Simon_Jester
Shroom thought of it, Rabid. It wasn't an expression of homophobia, it was just arbitrarily sticking the syllable "gay" wherever it would fit.

I think it originally came up in the context of a rather homoerotic Battlestar Galactica parody.
Rabid wrote:I hope no one here is colorblind ? :lol:
If they are, I can devise a truly eye-searing grayscale map for them. But that's a low-order priority.

Re: SDNW5 Map Discussion Thread

Posted: 2012-04-20 06:43pm
by Simon_Jester
[delete please]