Re: SD.Net World Redux Comment Thread VIII
Posted: 2009-05-12 07:37am
Hey PeZook, would a major PeZookian university and/or agency like to build something like the Huygens probe?
Get your fill of sci-fi, science, and mockery of stupid ideas
http://bbs.stardestroyer.net/
Well I haven't thought of it to tell you the truth. The semi constructed site is still sitting around though, and if your diplomats bring it up it could very well be restarted as a joint scientific project.Fingolfin_Noldor wrote:Raj, are you interested in reviving that particle collider?
I'm willing to restart it with funding from my High Energy Institute, and probably some from the UCSR. You could rope in your other Frequesue nations into it if you want.Raj Ahten wrote:Well I haven't thought of it to tell you the truth. The semi constructed site is still sitting around though, and if your diplomats bring it up it could very well be restarted as a joint scientific project.Fingolfin_Noldor wrote:Raj, are you interested in reviving that particle collider?
I'll try it out. Would racks of smaller missiles work?Stas Bush wrote:1) Coastal ships still need speed to be able to patrol their zones
2) River monitors are not supposed to engage the enemy with 1000m diameter missiles; they'd most likely have sufficient armament with a few large-caliber artillery guns...
500 tonnes each, or total?3) Consider the weight. I'm just approximating, but each Granit missile weighs 7 tons, yours would be even heavier. They'd weigh almost 500 tons, which is a large fraction of the ship's total tonnage. That can lead to unexpected performance changes during the firing...
Would it really be obscenely expensive? I haven't gone nuts and incorporated all the bells and whistles that the LCS has. In all seriousness, it just has a similar hull design because I liked the look of it.I just presumed building heavily armored river cutters for rivers and fast attack craft for coastal patrols is a more efficient solution to the problem. A large number of coastal attack craft is better than a few obscenely expensive half-monitors..
Indeed, as handled by a 20-year old with zero military experience and questionable engineering skills.But then, it's the Miratian approach to arms design
NotedSiegeTank wrote:And another world leader attempts to bring a ground convoy into San Dorado. I'm telling ya, none of you read those fancy brochures our diplomatic branch sends out! If you're a dignitary you travel by helicopter, if you're middle management you ride the overzoom or the monorails, and only if you're totally desperate or feeling particularly suicidal you drive a car in San Dorado City highway traffic.
Honestly, you don't want to drive a motorcade into San Dorado. And even if you did we wouldn't let you, because it's bad press to have foreign leaders get stuck in Sprawl traffic in the middle of a blockwar or some other kind of upheaval. Instead we'll arrange for a helicade that'll happily carry you and your entourage to any of the numerous downtown heliports.
Welcome to San Dorado!
The summit has become a non-event that is sucking my patience and creativity. Let's just post the egreed results in OOC and be done with it; I'm quite frankly tired of it and have no desire to pursue it any more.Fingolfin_Noldor wrote:Shall we call a recess during the summit and discuss the final accord and then propose it?
*Sigh* While some points are easy to handwave, Frequesue's is something a bit more subtle...Coyote wrote:The summit has become a non-event that is sucking my patience and creativity. Let's just post the egreed results in OOC and be done with it; I'm quite frankly tired of it and have no desire to pursue it any more.Fingolfin_Noldor wrote:Shall we call a recess during the summit and discuss the final accord and then propose it?
That, and the ones in Mortimer's Claim make me edgy. If we're going to do peace-keeping missions there, they need to be multilateral, and they need to be announced before hand with details of who's sending exactly what and exactly where its being sent.SiegeTank wrote:The NFT is not signing anything until at least the matter of Tian Xian troops on the North-Frequesuan shores has been addressed. We didn't raise that point for shits and giggles, you know. Either this is settled in some concrete fashion or we'll consider the summit a total bust and strongly consider just leaving altogether.
By now the world leaders and other dignitaries have gone, and now it's up to the beauracrats to actually write shit.Coyote wrote:The summit has become a non-event that is sucking my patience and creativity. Let's just post the egreed results in OOC and be done with it; I'm quite frankly tired of it and have no desire to pursue it any more.Fingolfin_Noldor wrote:Shall we call a recess during the summit and discuss the final accord and then propose it?
Because god forbid I create a base on the other side of a fairly large river, and use that to invade you, instead of rolling up the land border I already have with you.Ryan Thunder wrote:That, and the ones in Mortimer's Claim make me edgy. If we're going to do peace-keeping missions there, they need to be multilateral, and they need to be announced before hand with details of who's sending exactly what and exactly where its being sent.SiegeTank wrote:The NFT is not signing anything until at least the matter of Tian Xian troops on the North-Frequesuan shores has been addressed. We didn't raise that point for shits and giggles, you know. Either this is settled in some concrete fashion or we'll consider the summit a total bust and strongly consider just leaving altogether.
Which is already defended, mind you. My coastal defenses on that coast are geared to deal with pirates and at worst, organized pirates. They're not meant to deal with advanced MESS kit, and rebuilding them to do so is expensive. That's an expense that, as you can imagine, I'm not too keen on paying right now.Beowulf wrote:Because god forbid I create a base on the other side of a fairly large river, and use that to invade you, instead of rolling up the land border I already have with you.Ryan Thunder wrote:That, and the ones in Mortimer's Claim make me edgy. If we're going to do peace-keeping missions there, they need to be multilateral, and they need to be announced before hand with details of who's sending exactly what and exactly where its being sent.SiegeTank wrote:The NFT is not signing anything until at least the matter of Tian Xian troops on the North-Frequesuan shores has been addressed. We didn't raise that point for shits and giggles, you know. Either this is settled in some concrete fashion or we'll consider the summit a total bust and strongly consider just leaving altogether.
Beowulf wrote:And as for the construction of the naval base in the jungles of North Frequesque, which everyone acknowledges as Terra Nullis, that is, uninhabited and ungoverned, that base will remain. Considering there aren't any fighter or bomb wings stationed there, it's no where near as threatening as you try to make it seem. My avatar doesn't take demands from a pissant country very well. And it's not as if the UCSR base in Livorno isn't threatening to me and Karmic.
And yet, it'd make no difference, because if I really wanted to invade you, I'd just stage from Tian Jiao, and go right up the river. Of course, the more likely scenario is that I'd just destroy you, and damn the idea of invading. Much cheaper in blood and treasure.Ryan Thunder wrote:Which is already defended, mind you. My coastal defenses on that coast are geared to deal with pirates and at worst, organized pirates. They're not meant to deal with advanced MESS kit, and rebuilding them to do so is expensive. That's an expense that, as you can imagine, I'm not too keen on paying right now.
Yup, a base with no ships and only helicopters as the aircraft permanently stationed there is a clear and present threat. You're going to need more than a stick to convince me to remove it. Unfortunately, I can't think of any carrots that the NFT has.SiegeTank wrote:I see it's the same old Tian Xian routine. Yada yada, pissant country, and so forth. That base of yours is a clear and present threat to my nation, and if you're unwilling to negotiate its removal we'll draw our conclusions from that. I.e. screw the summit, and we'll reinforce the missile launchers.
And again, I have defenses against a MESS invasion staged from Tian Jiao that'd whittle away at whatever task force you'd send up that way. For all the good it'd do, since you'd probably just overwhelm them, anyway.Beowulf wrote:And yet, it'd make no difference, because if I really wanted to invade you, I'd just stage from Tian Jiao, and go right up the river.Ryan Thunder wrote:Which is already defended, mind you. My coastal defenses on that coast are geared to deal with pirates and at worst, organized pirates. They're not meant to deal with advanced MESS kit, and rebuilding them to do so is expensive. That's an expense that, as you can imagine, I'm not too keen on paying right now.
Well, of course. Hence the agreement with CATO. The point was that "Assuming you were to invade..."Of course, the more likely scenario is that I'd just destroy you, and damn the idea of invading. Much cheaper in blood and treasure.
It's 'no ships and only helicopters' now, but the fact is that once there's a base up and running there it'll be easy to expand it to include ships and fighters and who knows what else. The point remains: if you're unwilling to negotiate this point than as far as we're concerned the summit is a total farce and we might just as well not have convened it in the first place.Beowulf wrote:Yup, a base with no ships and only helicopters as the aircraft permanently stationed there is a clear and present threat. You're going to need more than a stick to convince me to remove it. Unfortunately, I can't think of any carrots that the NFT has.