Re: ReadLetterMedia reviews Avatar
Posted: 2010-02-08 03:41am
Lets recap: you
1) only bother applying the laws of physics when they suit your argument, but when someone starts saying that something you have asserted flies in the face of science and visual evidence suddenly its "who are we to say our laws of physics apply?"
2) you think that any time a character says something, no matter how stupid, unscientific, or contradicted by visuals it is it is true by default and the person who challenges this is the one who must prove the character is lying or doesn't know what he is talking about, Occams Razor be damned.
3) Jedi Mysticism is oh so important to the story of Star Wars that anything which challenges it, no matter if it makes sense to the characters or story and despite the general laziness of using the Force as a catchall plot device when Jedi are involved, must be George Lucas insulting you personally, even though this is childish and the way you said it was even more childish.
4) you abuse the canon policy even though the movie's visuals prove the official explanation is bullshit.
5) in general, you can't show one example of a problem with TPM which actually affected the plot of the story in similar fashion to the stupid climax of AotC even though this is what I challenged you to do. All your examples save for the one about the nerve gas (which was consistent with the incompetence of the trade fed anyway) are on details which personally offended your tastes.
Sounds about right for a fanwhore's way of thinking.
1) only bother applying the laws of physics when they suit your argument, but when someone starts saying that something you have asserted flies in the face of science and visual evidence suddenly its "who are we to say our laws of physics apply?"
2) you think that any time a character says something, no matter how stupid, unscientific, or contradicted by visuals it is it is true by default and the person who challenges this is the one who must prove the character is lying or doesn't know what he is talking about, Occams Razor be damned.
3) Jedi Mysticism is oh so important to the story of Star Wars that anything which challenges it, no matter if it makes sense to the characters or story and despite the general laziness of using the Force as a catchall plot device when Jedi are involved, must be George Lucas insulting you personally, even though this is childish and the way you said it was even more childish.
4) you abuse the canon policy even though the movie's visuals prove the official explanation is bullshit.
5) in general, you can't show one example of a problem with TPM which actually affected the plot of the story in similar fashion to the stupid climax of AotC even though this is what I challenged you to do. All your examples save for the one about the nerve gas (which was consistent with the incompetence of the trade fed anyway) are on details which personally offended your tastes.
Sounds about right for a fanwhore's way of thinking.