Search found 136 matches

by marsh8472
2010-03-01 05:58am
Forum: Parting Shots
Topic: [marsh8472] Bye, asshole
Replies: 9
Views: 27292

Marsh8472 - false allegations are fun

Also, your vid has been reported to photobucket for containing copyrighted material owned by paramount in violation of their Terms of Service. That's okay, I reported all your pictures at http://mmg.photobucket.com/albums/CaptainChewbacca for random reasons and your myspace crankygeologist account ...
by marsh8472
2010-02-24 12:07pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: I need some debate help
Replies: 229
Views: 59219

Re: I need some debate help

Actually, we see fighters being hit from the side in ANH by turbolasers. Granted, those were not heavy turbolasers, but they are still well within the high-MT range - exceeding any non-superweapon in Trek. And since Trek-ships are way bigger than fighters (hundreds of meters as compared to ~12 mete...
by marsh8472
2010-02-24 11:51am
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

First of all you do need to transport the whole ship or are you going to steal local ship the same ship THREE different times at intervals of 6 and 25 years that is assuming that the alt verse ships are even capable of performing the required task. Secondly I haven't forgotten the events of one of ...
by marsh8472
2010-02-24 11:34am
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: I need some debate help
Replies: 229
Views: 59219

Re: I need some debate help

As evidenced by-what, exactly? From voyager episode "rise" Chakotay: "That asteroid should have been vaporized. What happened?" Kim: "I'm not sure. Sensors showed a simple nickel-iron composition. We shouldn't be seeing fragments more than a centimeter in diameter. Plus kim...
by marsh8472
2010-02-24 11:05am
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

Facepalm MK.3 *Sigh* In the history of Trek I've NEVER seen the Federation transport a ship and I'm not even going to touch acts of Q. While I can easily accept the possibility of the alternate universe part Never have i seen the Federation have the capability of sending a whole star ship through a...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 10:15pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

I found the "tilotny throws a shape" story in the Star Wars Devilwars 2 comic book. http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v189/Marsh8472/starwars_timetravel.jpg here's how wiki describes the story At another time during the Galactic Civil War, Princess Leia Organa, fleeing from the Empire, cra...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 05:15pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

It's not that unrealistic. In episodes "Mirror, Mirror" TOS, "Through the Looking Glass" DS9, "Shattered Mirror" DS9, "Resurrection" DS9, and "The Emperor's New Cloak" DS9 we see them go to another universe by use of a transporter.
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 05:06pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

I really don't see your point. We see the borg, sphere builders, xindi, krenim, Na'kuhl, use time travel to wipe out their enemies. Just because we don't see them do it with each of their enemies doesn't mean they don't try, aren't doing it, or still aren't capable of doing it but choose not to. Lo...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 05:04pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

The anomaly cannot destroy the whole universe then if you're going to define it like that. The anomoly should only affect the parts of space which were created from the expansion of our big bang. I was assuming that's what we were talking about when we said universe. It shouldn't be able to reach a...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:58pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

I really don't see your point. We see the borg, sphere builders, xindi, krenim, Na'kuhl, use time travel to wipe out their enemies. Just because we don't see them do it with each of their enemies doesn't mean they don't try, aren't doing it, or still are capable of doing it but choose not to.
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:45pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

Otherwise I'd have to accept that time travel never occurred on star trek which would be a lie. Or you could just accept alternate theories on how that time travel works. yeah but it's still not going to change anything. I'm not even using theories here, I'm just telling you what the response will ...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:39pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

Hey, stop that Moron Trek for a moment - BY DEFINITION, if you can reach it, it IS the same universe. Since any "mulitverse" theory includes splitting of the alternate universes as time progresses, you will eventually reach everyone. But nevertheless - if you START the damn thing in your ...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:31pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

What you say it pointless though. I don't need to read a theory by your master to know that. This is going to be my answer regardless of what you show me: If the conservation of energy is true then time travel is impossible. <-- if this statement is true then I don't believe that the conservation of...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:24pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

Okay well you'd have to prove that star trek and star wars are in the same universe too. They are different tv shows afterall. Since we don't see the force demonstrated on star trek we can see the physical laws work differently. Let's just say that the federation find a way to get to the star wars ...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:14pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

Do you accept the principle of conservation of energy or not? If we cannot agree on such basic concepts, the debate is even more pointless than I figured. If I say no will you stop posting in the thread? Plus you'll have to be more specific since there's a difference between the conservation of ene...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 04:07pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

Okay well you'd have to prove that star trek and star wars are in the same universe too. They are different tv shows afterall. Since we don't see the force demonstrated on star trek we can see the physical laws work differently. Let's just say that the federation find a way to get to the star wars u...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 03:39pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

Why not? Leaving aside questions as to the Big Bang, why could it not grow forever, given that ordinary time is supposed to continue plodding forwards forever*. * Although I suppose that in the event of a heat death or big crunch you could say it stops, but that's kinda like the Big Bang for anti-t...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 03:36pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

An alternate reality is not the same thing as a universe. A (or, more accurately, the) universe is defined as the sum total of existence that we can perceive. If we can perceive alternate realities, they are part of our universe; the fact that they are often colloquially referred to as "parall...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 03:18pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

1. Those are generally by other civilisations, ones which might be expected to have a greater regard for the timeline than the Borg. 2. It is still a rare thing. 3. It is woefully underused as a means of, well, doing a lot of things TBH. 4. We only see the Borg doing it once, maybe twice. He said t...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 03:01pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

Why not? Leaving aside questions as to the Big Bang, why could it not grow forever, given that ordinary time is supposed to continue plodding forwards forever*. * Although I suppose that in the event of a heat death or big crunch you could say it stops, but that's kinda like the Big Bang for anti-t...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 02:49pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

I thought that the mass/energy content of the universe would remain constant, regardless of expansion? It was my understanding that no new energy is ever created, but only converted into different forms? we see these laws demonstrated in our little corner but there's no proof the laws hold up in th...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 02:43pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

BORG QUEEN (OC): What's wrong Locutus? Isn't this familiar? BORG QUEEN: Organic minds are such fragile things. How could you forget me so quickly? We were very close, you and I. You can still hear our song. PICARD: Yes, ...I remember you. You were there all the time. But that ship and all the Borg ...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 02:03pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

They go back 3 and a half billion years and the anomaly is only the size of a quarter of a single galaxy. They think the universe is only 14 billion years old and arguably time didn't exist before this point. The issue of time beginning with the big bang is best left to philosophy and is an unknown...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 01:43pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)
Replies: 218
Views: 63238

Re: How to destroy all life in the star wars galaxy (easy steps)

SUISIDAL UNATURAL PHENOMANON IS NOT TECHNOLOGY!!!!!!!! IT GETS BIGGER AS IT GOES BACK IN TIME EVENTUALY REACHING THE MILKY WAY AND DESTOYES ALL LIFE THERE TOO. IT'S NOT SANE EVEN IF IT DID WORK!! Already addressed this. It presumes that it can grow that far and is capable of continuing to grow befo...
by marsh8472
2010-02-23 01:40pm
Forum: Star Wars vs Star Trek
Topic: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars
Replies: 85
Views: 31045

Re: Borg with their time travel technology vs Star Wars

A universe is by definition self-contained. Even assuming that there is somehow interaction between two different universes, there can be no net increase or decrease in the mass/energy content of either without it violating conservation of energy. Darth Wong addresses this on his page on common fal...